Sure of himself, right up until he isn't
Two beers in, a game nobody's watching, and a hand that rests on a thigh one second too long. Straight guy gay stories are about the man who has a girlfriend, an answer for everything and no idea why he can't stop looking. They're explicit, for adults, and they take their time with the part where he admits it.
The other man usually knows before he does. Sometimes he waits. Sometimes he makes the first move and lets the straight guy decide what happens next.













