Chapter 5
Tide Between · Chapter 5 of 5

Chapter 5

Tane's last night before the flight to Auckland. This is the final chapter: bring the story to its ending. The act this chapter delivers: Both men fuck Leilani together on the deck under the stars and come inside her; she says goodbye to Tane and lets him go. The story ends.

The deck boards were cold under Leilani's bare feet, cold the way timber only gets after the sun has gone off it and the sea air has had hours to work. Above her the stars sat hard and low, the kind of night Byron gave you in the shoulder season when the humidity finally broke. Three glasses stood on the rail. Two of them had ice in them still. The third was empty and had been for a while, and she couldn't remember which of them had drunk it.

Tane's camera bag sat by the rail where he'd set it down, the strap still looped over the top of the post as if he'd meant to pick it up again in a minute and hadn't. It had been there all evening. She'd caught herself looking at it three times now, the way you look at a clock you don't want to read.

"You packed," Gareth said.

Tane didn't turn around. He was leaning on the rail with his forearms, looking down at the beach, where the surf was a white line that kept arriving and kept being erased. "Mostly."

"Mostly means the bag's by the door and the bag's on the rail."

"Mostly means I've got a shirt in the wash." Tane's laugh was low and didn't last. "Flight's at eleven. It's a forty-minute drive to Ballina and I've never once made it in forty minutes."

Leilani picked up the empty glass and turned it in her hands. The ice had gone to water and the water had gone to nothing. She was thirty-five years old and she had known this man since she was a girl at Makaha, and tomorrow he would get in a hire car and drive south and be gone, and she would be standing on this deck with her husband and the same stars overhead and one less person in the world who knew what her face did when she was about to go under.

"You don't have to stand out here being polite," she said. "If you've got packing."

"I'm not being polite."

"Then what are you doing?"

Tane straightened up off the rail and looked at her properly for the first time since the plates had been cleared. There was a bruise of tiredness under his eyes that hadn't been there a week ago. "I'm standing on your deck," he said. "I'm not in a hurry to stop."

The surf came up the beach and went back down. Somewhere below the house a possum went through the bin and thought better of it.

Gareth moved. He'd been at the far end of the rail with his back to the ocean, and now he came along it, unhurried, his heels quiet on the boards, and stopped where the three of them made a loose triangle with the rail. His towel was still over his shoulder from the shower, though his hair had dried hours ago. He took it off and folded it and set it on the rail beside the glasses, squaring the edges without seeming to think about it.

"I meant it," he said.

Neither of them asked what.

"This morning. What I said in the shower." Gareth's voice was the one he used on the beach when he was talking somebody out of a rip — flat, certain, no room in it for the water to argue. "I didn't say it because the moment was hot and I wanted to see what happened. I said it because I've thought about it, and I want it, and I'm not going to pretend tomorrow that I didn't." He looked at Tane. "You're on a plane in the morning. So this is the night. Whatever this is, it happens tonight, and nothing about it gets taken back in the light of day."

Tane's jaw worked once. His hand was on the rail and his thumb had found a splinter of paint and was worrying at it. "You've thought about it," he said.

"I've thought about it."

"And you're all right."

"I'm not all right," Gareth said. "I'm here. That's different."

Leilani felt the deck tilt under her, just slightly, the way it did when a wave she hadn't seen broke close. She had spent a week watching these two men be careful with each other across a kitchen table, and now the careful thing had been set down, and she could hear the surf filling the place where the careful thing had been.

"Lei," Gareth said, not looking at her. "Your call. Not mine."

She set the glass down on the rail, and her hand wasn't quite steady, and she let it be seen. Then she crossed the boards to Tane and put her hand on the back of his neck.

He went still. Not the stillness of a man who didn't want it — the other kind, the kind that comes over a body when something it has been bracing against for a long time finally arrives. She felt the muscle under her palm go hard and then, slowly, give. His pulse was going in his throat. Her thumb found the place behind his ear where the hair was short and coarse and she remembered exactly how it had felt under her thumb at twenty-two, in the dark of a car outside her mother's house.

"You're sure," he said. It came out rough.

"I'm sure."

"Gareth—"

"Gareth's standing right there," she said. "He can hear you ask."

Tane's eyes went past her shoulder. Whatever he saw in Gareth's face, it took the last of the bracing out of him. He turned his head and his mouth found her wrist where it lay against his jaw. He kissed it, open, the flat of his tongue on the thin skin over the veins, and she felt it go all the way up her arm into her teeth.

Then he kissed her.

It wasn't the shower kiss. The shower had been a man proving something to himself. This was slower and worse and better — his hands coming up to her waist and pulling her in until her hips were against his and she could feel him already hard through his shorts, and his mouth opening over hers with a sound low in his chest that she felt in her own sternum. He tasted of the beer he'd been nursing and salt. Her fingers went into his hair and closed.

Behind her, the boards creaked. Gareth had moved to the wide low bench along the back wall and sat down on it, his elbows on his knees, and his eyes were on them and he wasn't looking away. Not the way a man watches something he's tolerating. The way a man watches a thing he chose.

Tane's hand slid down and found the hem of her singlet and went under it, up her back, flat and hot, and she arched into it before she'd decided to. His other hand was at the tie of her shorts. He pulled it loose and the shorts went slack and his fingers found the waistband of her knickers and stopped there, and he broke the kiss to breathe against her mouth.

"Tell me," he said.

"Take them off."

He took them off. The shorts and the knickers together, down her legs, and she stepped out of them and the night air came up between her thighs and she heard herself make a small sound at how wet she already was, exposed like that under the stars with the sea going on below and her husband six feet away on the bench.

Tane went down onto his knees on the cold boards. He got his shoulder under her thigh and lifted her leg over it, and his mouth found the inside of her knee first, then higher, and she put her hand on the top of his head and her other hand out to the rail to hold herself up, and she looked past her own arm at Gareth.

"Look at me," Gareth said.

She looked at him. Tane's tongue went flat and slow up the whole length of her cunt and her hips bucked. She kept her eyes on her husband's face while it happened, and Gareth's jaw was tight and his hands were loose between his knees. He held her gaze like it was a rope he was paying out.

"Again," Gareth said, and it wasn't to her.

Tane did it again. Then his tongue found her clit and stayed there, working it in slow circles and then faster, and two of his fingers pushed up into her and curled. She heard the wet sound of it over the surf and her own breathing going high and thin. Her thigh was shaking against his ear. She gripped the rail and the rail was cold and solid and the only thing in the world that wasn't moving.

"Don't let her come yet," Gareth said.

Tane's mouth came off her. He rested his forehead against her thigh and laughed, a wrecked little breath of a laugh, and his fingers stayed inside her, still. She could feel them there, thick and patient, while her cunt clenched around them and got nothing.

"You're a hard man," Tane said into her leg.

"You've no idea." Gareth stood up off the bench. He came across the boards and stood behind her, and his hands came down on her shoulders, and he bent and put his mouth to her ear. "You want him inside you?"

"Yes."

"Say it to him."

She looked down at Tane on his knees, his mouth wet, his eyes dark and up on her. "I want you inside me," she said. "Tane. Please."

He got up off the boards. He got his shorts down and his cock out and it was thick and dark and shining at the tip and she reached for it and got her hand around it and felt it jump at her palm, and he hissed through his teeth and caught her wrist.

"Not standing up," he said. "I'll not last."

Gareth's hands turned her. There was a long low daybed along the back wall of the deck, under the overhang, with a canvas cushion on it and a folded blanket she'd put out that morning and never taken in. Gareth took her by the hips and walked her back to it and she sat down and lay back, and the canvas was rough under her arse and the stars were overhead past the edge of the roofline.

Tane came down over her. His knees on the cushion either side of her hips, his chest against hers, the hot length of him lying along her belly, and he kissed her again, slower. She got her hand between them and guided him down and felt the blunt head of his cock find her and push.

She was wet enough that he went in easy, and that was its own kind of unbearable — the way he slid into her to the root in one long stroke and her body just took him, opened for him, remembered him. His forehead came down onto hers. He didn't move. His breath was hot and uneven on her mouth.

"Lei," he said.

"I know."

He pulled back and pushed in again, and this time it was slow and deliberate. She felt every inch of it, the drag of him out of her and the stretch of him back in, and her heels came up and her hands went to his shoulders and her nails dug in. The daybed creaked. He found a rhythm, deep and rolling, and the canvas rasped under her back with every thrust. She could hear how wet she was, the sound of it under the sound of the sea.

Gareth was at the end of the daybed. He'd pulled the low stool over and he sat on it with his forearms on his knees, close enough to touch, and he watched Tane's arse and back work and he watched her face.

"How does he feel," he said.

"Gareth—"

"How does he feel."

"Full," she got out. "He feels — God. He fills me up."

Tane groaned against her throat and his rhythm broke and went harder. She heard herself cry out and clamped her hand over her own mouth, because the neighbours, because the whole street, because it was two in the morning. She was being fucked on her own deck under the stars and she did not care, she did not care, and she took her hand away.

Gareth stood. He got up off the stool and came round to the head of the daybed and stood there looking down at her. Then he was undoing his shorts, and his cock came out thick and flushed. She turned her head on the cushion and opened her mouth for it.

He fed it to her slow. She got her lips round the head and her tongue flat under it. He pushed in until she felt it at the back of her throat and held there. She breathed through her nose and took it, and Tane was still driving into her, and the two of them found a rhythm between them without a word, one pushing in as the other pulled back, so that she was never empty and never unpressed, filled at both ends of her with the sea going on below.

It went on. She lost the count of the waves. Her jaw ached and her cunt ached. She was so wet now that Tane's cock came out of her shining every time and went back in with a sound that made her ears burn. Gareth pulled out of her mouth and let her breathe. She gasped and looked up at him with her eyes streaming. He wiped her cheek with his thumb, once, and put it back in.

"I'm close," Tane said. It came out cracked. "Lei. I'm — where do you want it."

Gareth pulled out of her mouth. "Inside her," he said. "You don't pull out of her."

Tane made a sound like it had been punched out of him and his hips slammed in and he stayed there, buried. She felt him come — felt his cock jerk and pulse and spill into her, hot, and his whole body shook over her and his hands were fists in the canvas either side of her head. He was saying something in Māori into her neck that she didn't catch and didn't need to.

He held himself there until it was done. Then he pulled out slow and she felt the wet of him follow. He sat back on his heels on the daybed, wrecked, his chest heaving, his cock still half-hard and slick with her and his own come.

Gareth looked at the two of them for a moment. Then he knelt down on the daybed and put his hand flat on her belly, low, and pushed her thighs wider with his knee.

"My turn," he said.

He pushed into her. She was so full of Tane's come that it was slick and easy and obscene, and Gareth felt it and his breath went out of him in a shudder. He said, "Christ." Then he was fucking her, hard and steady, the way he did everything, and Tane was beside them with his hand on her breast and his mouth on her shoulder, murmuring to her in that low rumble, telling her how she looked, telling her she was beautiful, telling her to let go.

She came with Gareth's cock in her and Tane's come in her and Tane's mouth on her neck. It went through her in long hard waves that made her heels drum on the canvas. She heard herself saying both their names, one and then the other, and Gareth drove in deep and came too, his hips stuttering. She felt him spill into her on top of Tane, and the deck and the stars and the surf all went quiet and far away.

Nobody moved for a long time. Gareth stayed where he was, his forehead down on hers, breathing. Then he pulled out and sat back and the night air came at her wet cunt. She shivered all over.

Tane got the folded blanket off the end of the daybed and pulled it over her. Then he lay down beside her on the canvas, on his side, his arm over her waist, and Gareth lay down on her other side, and the three of them lay there under the overhang with the stars past the roofline and the surf going on down the beach, and nobody said anything at all.

It was a while before Tane spoke. "I need to be at Ballina by half nine," he said, to the dark.

"I know," Leilani said.

His arm tightened across her. "I'll go and get my shirt out of the wash."

"In a minute."

"In a minute," he agreed, and stayed.

The minute went by. Then another. Tane's arm stayed across her waist, and his breathing went deep and even the way it did when a man was deciding whether to let himself fall asleep, and then it changed, and he stirred.

"Right," he said, and got up off the daybed with the blanket dragging off her hip. Cold came in where his body had been. He found his shorts on the boards and pulled them on, and went round the side of the house in the dark for the laundry.

Gareth hadn't moved. He lay on his back with one arm behind his head, looking up past the roofline. His chest was still going a little fast.

"You all right," Leilani said. It wasn't quite a question either.

"Yeah." He turned his head on the canvas. "You?"

"I don't know what I am."

"That's not a no."

The laundry door banged. Tane came back with his shirt in his hand, still damp, and he stood at the end of the daybed looking at the two of them like he'd come back into a room he wasn't sure he was allowed in.

"Sit down," Gareth said.

He sat. On the edge of the daybed, near her feet, his damp shirt across his knees. The three of them in the dark under the overhang, the surf going on down the beach like it had all night and would all night regardless.

Leilani pulled the blanket up over her chest and sat up against the wall. The canvas was rough on her back and there was a wet patch under her that she decided not to think about yet.

"So," she said.

"So," Gareth said.

Tane laughed — the low one, no length to it. "You two are going to make me say it."

"No," Gareth said. "I'm going to say it. I said this morning I meant it. I meant it then, and I've meant it for the last hour, and I'll mean it when the sun's up, which is the part I want you to hear, because I know what I am and I know what I'm not." He sat up, and his voice was the flat one off the beach. "I'm not doing this to be generous. I'm not doing it because I want to watch my wife get something she's owed. I'm doing it because I want it. That's the whole of it. It's mine too."

Tane turned his shirt over in his hands. "You're not going to ask me to leave after."

"No."

"Because I've been the one who leaves. I'd rather be told."

Gareth looked at him a long moment. "You can stay tonight. You can stay the week. But I'm not going to be the man who keeps you here with a hand on your back. You've a flight. You know what's at the end of the drive."

"I do."

"Then don't tell me tonight. Tell me when you know."

Leilani put her hand out and found Tane's knee — the scarred one, the old cut long healed under her palm. "I don't want it done in the morning," she said. "Not the way you did it before. Not a bag by the door and a note on the counter."

"It wasn't a note," Tane said. "It was a shell."

"It was a shell on the counter and you gone, and I sat in that shop for a week looking at it."

He was quiet. His hand came down over hers on his knee and held it there. "I was twenty-eight years old and I thought if I stayed another day I'd never leave, and I'd decided I had to leave, so I made it quick. That's all it was. It wasn't that I didn't—" He stopped. Started again. "I've had eight years to work out how to say the rest of that sentence and I still haven't got it."

"Then don't say it tonight," Gareth said. "You've a week."

Tane looked over at him, and something went across his face — not the check from before, something slower and more tired, a man being given a thing he hadn't asked for and didn't know yet what to do with. "You're a strange man, Gareth Vaughan."

"I've been told."

Leilani got up. Her legs were not entirely her own. She took a step and felt Tane's come move inside her, warm and slick down the inside of her thigh. She stood there in the dark with the blanket round her shoulders and let it happen, let herself feel it, because it was true. It had happened and there was no undoing any of it now. She went to the rail and looked down at the beach. The white line kept arriving and kept being erased.

"I want to say something," she said, with her back to them. "And I want to say it now, while it's still dark, because I don't trust myself to say it in daylight."

Neither of them spoke.

"I married you," she said, to the beach, to Gareth. "I chose you. I've chosen you every day for six years and I'll choose you tomorrow. That's not in question and it never has been." She turned round. "And I'm not going to stand here and pretend this was a favour you did me, or a thing I got away with. I wanted him. I've wanted him since I was twenty-two and I'll probably want him when I'm sixty. Both those things are true at once and I'm done apologising for the shape of it."

Gareth had his elbows on his knees. He looked at her for a long time. "I know," he said. "That's why I asked."

Tane got up off the daybed. He came and stood beside her at the rail, close but not touching, and the two of them looked down at the surf together with Gareth behind them on the canvas, and for a moment the deck held all three of them the way the sea holds three stones.

"I'll get my things," Tane said. "I'll sleep in the guest room. If that's — if that's what's wanted."

"It's what's wanted," Gareth said.

Tane went inside. The screen door clicked shut behind him and the house went dark room by dark room as he went through it.

Leilani came back and sat down on the daybed next to her husband. He put his arm round her and she leaned into him and the blanket was between them and the canvas was cold and the night was going grey at the edge of the sky over the water.

"I counted four," Gareth said.

"Four what?"

"Laughs. On the beach, this morning. Before I came down. I counted four, and I thought, that's the laugh she had before me, and I'm hearing it now, and I don't know what to do with that, so I came down." He rubbed his thumb along her shoulder. "I've been thinking about it all night. Whether I came down because I wanted to give you something, or because I couldn't stand to be the man who wasn't in the room."

"Which was it?"

"Both," he said. "I'm not a saint, Lei. I'm a man who saw his wife laugh like that and wanted to be the one who let her."

She turned her face into his shoulder. "That's not nothing."

"No." His hand came up and settled in her hair. "It's not nothing."

They sat there until the sky was properly grey and the first birds started up in the trees behind the house, and the surf kept arriving and kept being erased, and neither of them said anything else worth remembering, because there was nothing left to say that hadn't been said.

Inside, a door opened. Tane's voice came through the house, low and easy, the way it did when he was talking to no one in particular. "Kettle's on. If either of you want tea."

Gareth looked at Leilani. She looked back at him. Then she got up off the daybed with the blanket round her shoulders and went inside, and he followed her, and the screen door clicked shut behind them both.

The kettle was still ticking when she came into the kitchen. Tane had found three mugs — mismatched, one of them the fat yellow one Gareth had brought from Cardiff and refused to throw out — and lined them up on the counter like a man setting up a shot. The overhead light was off. The grey coming through the window was enough.

Leilani put her back to the counter and let the blanket drop off one shoulder. "You didn't have to do that."

"Do what."

"Make it normal."

"It is normal." He poured. Steam came up and fogged the window a hand's width. "I've been awake all night in that room with the window open listening to the two of you talk, and now I'm making tea. That's about as normal as I get."

Gareth came in behind her, and the kitchen got smaller. He took the yellow mug without being offered it. He stood at the end of the counter with his hip against it, watching the two of them over the rim, and he had the look he got on the tower when the swell was building and he hadn't decided yet whether to raise the flag.

"I want to say the thing," Leilani said. "Before the tea's cold. Because I've said a lot tonight and I don't want to leave the important one out."

"Go on," Gareth said.

She looked at Tane. "I'm not asking you to choose me over Auckland. I'm not asking you to stay for me at all. I'm asking you to stop making the decision in the dark and handing it to me in the morning like a bill." She wrapped both hands round her mug. "That's the only thing I need. Not the rest of it. That."

Tane set his mug down. He didn't answer straight away — he turned the yellow one round on the counter so the handle faced Gareth, a small tidy thing, the way he did with lenses. "Eight years ago I decided for both of us and told myself it was kindness. It wasn't. It was me being a coward in a hurry." He looked up. "I'm not going to do it that way again. If I go, you'll hear it from me, standing in front of you, with time to say something back."

"That's all I want," she said.

"It's not all," Gareth said, and both of them turned. He set his mug down. "It's the part that keeps her safe from the old thing. It's not the part that tells me what I am in this house." He looked at Tane steadily. "So I'll say my piece, and then I'll shut up about it. I'm not your host and I'm not your landlord. I'm her husband, and I'm here because I want to be here, and if that's a strange thing for a man to want then I'll be strange about it for the week and you can both get used to it."

Tane laughed — short, surprised out of him. "You've a gift for making the strange thing sound like a fence post."

"It's a Welsh thing."

"It's not."

"No," Gareth admitted. "It's a me thing."

Leilani put her mug down and stepped between them, and she put one hand flat on each of their chests, and she felt both hearts going under her palms at different speeds, and she thought — with a clarity that surprised her, standing in her own kitchen in the grey with a blanket round her hips — that she had spent six years being careful and one night being honest and she was not going back to careful.

"Here's what this is," she said. "This week, this is what it is. Tane sleeps in the guest room and eats at this table and shoots his waves, and I go to the shop and I come home, and Gareth is in this house because it's his house. Nobody hides. Nobody pretends at breakfast. If it gets too big for one of us, that one says so, out loud, and we don't make them sorry for it." She looked at Gareth. "Yes?"

"Yes."

She looked at Tane. "Yes?"

He covered her hand on his chest with his own — the callused one, the one that had held a camera in front of her face a hundred times and never once touched her like this. "Yes," he said. "And when the week's up I'll tell you what I've decided. Standing in front of you. With time to say something back."

"Good," she said. "Then drink your tea."

They drank their tea. The birds got louder. Somewhere down the beach a dog started up and stopped, and the light came up over the water and made the yellow mug glow like something lit from inside, and none of them said anything for a while, which was, Leilani thought, its own kind of answer.

Then Tane rinsed his mug and set it upside down on the board. "I'm going to sleep," he said. "Actual sleep. In an actual bed. Alone." He paused at the doorway. "That's not a complaint."

"Didn't sound like one," Gareth said.

He went. They heard the guest-room door, and then the window being pushed wider, and then nothing.

Gareth came round the counter and put his arms round her from behind, and his chin came down on the top of her head, and he was warm and a little damp and he smelled of salt and canvas. "You meant it," he said. "The bit about not making them sorry for it."

"I meant it."

"Because I'll be the one who's too big for the room sometimes. I know that about myself."

"Then you'll say so," she said, "and I'll not make you sorry."

He was quiet. Then he turned her round and kissed her, unhurried, with the tea still on his tongue, and she kissed him back and felt the whole night settle into its shape at last, and when they broke apart the sun was properly up over the water and the kitchen was full of it.

"Come to bed," he said.

"It's morning."

"It is." He took her hand. "Come to bed anyway."

She went. The blanket stayed on the kitchen floor where it fell, and the screen door stood open behind them, and the three mugs sat upside down on the board drying in the light.

Comments

Be the first to share your thoughts on this chapter.

The End

Thanks for reading