The barrel cave smelled of oak and old rain. Priya had been down here a hundred times with a tasting glass in her hand, but never with her cheek pressed to the cool leather of the padded bench, never with her hands strapped at the small of her back and her ankles cinched to the bench's far legs so that her soles stood up into the dark like two pale offerings.
The stone above her held the day's heat at bay. Below, the temperature dropped another ten degrees, and she could feel it on the wet places—the backs of her knees, the crease where her thighs met the leather, the bare arch of each foot. Her dress was somewhere. Her underwear, too. She didn't remember handing them over. She remembered the card.
"Read the inside," she said, and her voice came out muffled by leather. "You said there was an inside."
Gemma's boots moved on the stone. Then she crouched, and the card appeared in Priya's line of sight, held at the corner between two calloused fingers. The inside was handwritten in the same brown ink, in a hand that slanted harder than the front—as if whoever wrote it had borne down.
"Rule five." Gemma's voice was gravel over honey, close to the floor. "The guest does not come until she asks out loud. Plainly. No hints."
"I can do that."
"Rule six." Gemma turned the card a little. "Anything the guest says that is not a rule, a name, or a yes can be used against her."
Priya turned her head far enough to see Gemma's face, silver crop and all, the fine lines at her eyes catching the lantern light. "That's not a rule. That's a threat with paperwork."
"It's a rule," Gemma said. "You may refuse it."
The cave ticked. Somewhere above the hill, a tractor idled and died, and the sound dropped into the dark like a stone down a well. Priya flexed her fingers against the leather straps and found them snug but not biting—Rhys had checked each one twice, sliding two fingers under the webbing, watching her face while he did it. She had watched him back. She had said yes to every strap.
"I accept rule six," she said.
Gemma set the card face-down on the bench's edge, exactly as she'd done upstairs, and smoothed it flat with her palm. "Good. Rhys has the brush."
"The—"
The brush touched the arch of her right foot, and Priya's whole body flinched against the straps before she knew it was happening. It was a makeup brush, she realized in the first half-second—soft, absurdly soft, the kind of thing that had no business down here among the barrels. Its bristles dragged up from her heel to the ball of her foot in a slow, even line, and it was like being traced with a feather made of cold air. Her leg jerked. The strap held. A sound came out of her that she had never made before, a high, startled bark that echoed off the stone.
"There it is," Rhys said.
He was behind her, out of her sight, and she could hear the smile in it. She turned her face back to the leather and tried to breathe like a person who had not just barked. The brush lifted. She had half a second to brace—and then it came down again, slower this time, drawing a spiral around the ball of her foot, and the bracing was useless, was worse than useless, because she'd clenched her toes and the toes were worse, the toes were unbearable. She was laughing before the first circle was complete.
"Oh god—oh god—"
"Rule six," Gemma said mildly, from somewhere near her head.
Priya clamped her mouth shut. The brush found the space between her first and second toes and worked in, back and forth, and the laugh came out of her nose in a snort she could not stop, and then her mouth opened anyway and the laughter spilled out whole, helpless, echoing up into the vaulted dark. Her fingers curled and uncurled against the leather. The bench creaked under her hips.
"You're going to have to do better than that," Gemma said, and then her mouth closed over Priya's left foot.
Priya went rigid. Gemma's tongue slid between her big toe and the one beside it, hot and wet and slow. It was so different from the brush—the brush was cold dry whisper, and Gemma was heat and pressure and the rough drag of taste buds—that Priya's brain simply dropped the thread of what it had been doing. Her toes splayed apart. Gemma's tongue pushed between them like she was licking honey off a spoon, and the brush kept moving on the other foot, up and down the arch, and Priya was laughing and gasping on the same breath, no way to tell which was which.
"Rhys—Rhys, it's—" She lost the sentence. Her hips lifted off the bench, a slow involuntary arch, and came back down. The leather was warm now under her belly. "It's too much, it's—"
"Too much?" Gemma lifted her mouth just enough to speak. Her breath moved over Priya's wet toes. "That's not a rule, a name, or a yes."
"Gemma." Priya's voice cracked in the middle of it. "Gemma, please—"
"That's a name." Gemma's tongue slid back between her toes, and this time she sucked, hard, drawing the two smallest toes into her mouth and rolling her tongue around them, and Priya's laugh broke apart into something with no words in it at all. Her cheek ground against the leather. She could smell her own skin on it now, salt and the ghost of the morning's lotion, and under that the wine, always the wine, the oak and the dark fruit of forty vintages breathing in their barrels.
The brush stopped. Priya sagged, panting, and the relief lasted exactly as long as it took Rhys to walk around the bench and crouch at her head.
He looked at her for a while. His eyes were warm brown and unreadable, and his salt-and-pepper stubble had grown in since the morning, and he was still wearing the flannel, sleeves rolled. He smelled like the crush pad, like yeast and cold hose water.
"You're a mess," he said. Not unkindly.
"I know." Her breath was still coming short. "I can't—you have to understand, I can't control—"
"I know you can't." He reached out and pushed a strand of hair off her forehead, the same gesture as upstairs, and it undid her a little more than the brush had. "That's the point. The card says so." He glanced at the card on the bench's edge. "Rule seven. The guest is not permitted to hold still."
"That's not fair, that's not—"
"It's a rule." He stood. "You can refuse it."
She pressed her forehead to the leather and thought about refusing it. The thought lasted about a second and a half. "I accept rule seven."
"Good girl," Gemma said, from her foot, and the words went through Priya like a warm wire.
The brush came back. Rhys worked it now in earnest—short, fast strokes across the ball of her foot, then a long drag down the arch, then a flurry over the heel, and every time Priya's leg jerked or her hips bucked or her fingers scrabbled at the leather, she could hear him hum, low in his chest, satisfied. Gemma's mouth never left her other foot. She licked the length of each toe, one after another, drew them into her mouth and let them go with a soft wet sound. She was humming too, both of them humming, two notes in the dark, and Priya was caught between them like a wire strung between two posts and plucked.
"Please—" Her voice was wrecked. "Please, I can't—I need—"
"Need what?" Gemma lifted her head. Her lips were wet. "Say it plainly. Rule five."
Priya's face burned against the leather. The cave was cool and her skin was not. She could feel how wet she was, the slick of it between her thighs, the leather under her belly gone warm and damp, and the brush was still moving, patient, merciless. She understood that they would wait. That they had all night. That the card had an inside and the inside had no bottom.
"I need to be fucked," she said. Out loud. Plainly. It echoed off the barrels, and she heard her own voice come back to her from the dark, and it did not sound like a stranger's at all. "Please. I need one of you to fuck me."
The brush stopped. Gemma's mouth lifted away.
"There she is," Rhys said.
He set the brush down on the bench's edge, beside the card. She heard the clink of his belt buckle and the long slide of the leather through the loops, and her body answered before her mind did, a deep clench low in her belly that made her breath catch. Gemma got up off her knees and came around, and Priya felt her hand settle on the back of her neck, warm and steady, while Rhys's knee pressed the bench down behind her.
"The bench is the right height," Rhys said, more to Gemma than to her. "I checked it before we brought her down."
"You did not."
"I did." His hand closed over her hip, thumb pressing into the small of her back, and then his cock was there, sliding along her wet folds, and Priya made a sound into the leather that was not a laugh and not a word. He was thick and hot. He took his time, dragging the head of it up and down through her slick, and every pass made her clench on nothing. "Tell me again."
"Fuck me," she said. "Rhys. Fuck me."
He pushed into her.
The stretch pulled a long, low moan out of her, and she felt every inch of it—the slow give of her body around him, the way he stopped halfway to let her breathe, the way Gemma's hand tightened on her neck. "More," Priya said, and he gave her more. Then he was deep, seated to the hilt, his hips flush against her ass, and the bench creaked under them both.
"Good?" he asked.
"Yes—yes—"
He pulled back slow and pushed in fast, and the slap of it rang off the barrels. Priya's fingers curled into fists against the leather. He found a rhythm, deep and deliberate, and Gemma crouched at her head and watched her face, and Priya could not look away from those pale blue eyes, could not hide anything, and so she stopped trying. Her mouth fell open. Sounds came out of her that she had no name for. The straps held her wrists and ankles, and the not-being-able-to-move made it all sharper, made every thrust land somewhere new.
"She's close," Gemma said. "Look at her."
"I'm looking," Rhys said, and his hand slid up her spine, between her shoulder blades, and pressed her down into the leather. "Ask."
"Please—" Her voice was thin. The bench creaked. He was hitting something deep and steady now. She could feel it building, a heat at the base of her spine that spread out through her hips and down into her thighs. "Please let me come. Please."
"Gemma," Rhys said.
"Go on, then," Gemma said, and her thumb stroked the back of Priya's neck. "Come. Let's hear it."
Priya came with her face pressed to the leather and Gemma's hand on her neck and Rhys deep inside her. It went on longer than she thought a body could, wave after wave of it, her cunt clenching hard around his cock, her thighs shaking against the straps, a sound coming out of her that was almost a sob. Rhys kept moving through it, slower now, drawing it out, and then his hips stuttered and his fingers dug into her hip. He came with a low groan, buried deep, and she felt it—the heat of it, the pulse of him, the way he ground in and held.
For a while nobody said anything. The cave ticked. The lantern hissed. Priya lay with her cheek on the leather, breathing. She could feel Rhys's hand still on her back, heavy and warm, and Gemma's thumb still moving slow on her neck, and the wetness of her own tears drying on her face. She did not want either of them to move.
"The card's not finished," Gemma said at last, very quietly, and Priya heard her reach for it and turn it over on the bench's edge.

