Chapter 2
The Watch · Chapter 2 of 6

Chapter 2

The next night Marcus, 38, the Black jazz pianist from the bar, comes up to the room; Ben sits in the armchair; the rules are read once. The act this chapter delivers: Marcus undresses Claire, eats her pussy until she comes, then fucks her on the bed while Ben watches from the chair.

Ben set the chair where he wanted it before the knock came. He'd moved it twice already — once from the window, where the lamp threw his shadow across the bed and made a spectacle of him, and once from the corner, where he'd have had to crane his neck. Now it sat at the foot of the bed, angled slightly off-center, close enough that he could see everything and far enough that he wasn't in it. He sat. Stood. Wiped his palms on his trousers and sat again.

Claire watched him from the bathroom doorway, hairpin in her teeth, her chestnut twist half-pinned. "You're doing the thing," she said around it.

"What thing."

"The architect thing. Measuring the room." She took the pin out, slid it home, and her hair settled into its low coil. The black dress was the same one from the bar, but she'd put on the gold pendant tonight, the one he'd given her for their tenth anniversary, and it lay in the hollow of her throat like a small deliberate dare.

"It's a good chair," he said.

"It's a hotel chair."

"It's a good hotel chair."

She came and stood over him, and he saw that her hands were not steady — she was holding the folded paper and the paper was trembling slightly at its edge, the way paper does when a hand won't quite commit. She'd printed it that afternoon in the business center off the lobby, two copies, because she'd said if they were going to do this they were going to do it like adults, and Ben had laughed at her and then stopped laughing when he understood she meant it.

"You don't have to read it," she said. "I know it by heart."

"Read it."

"Ben—"

"I want to hear it out loud. In the room. Not just the two of us in the dark deciding things." He looked up at her, and his gray eyes were doing the thing they did when he'd made up his mind and wanted her to see it. "Read it to him."

She held his gaze a moment longer than she needed to. Then she nodded, once, and went to the window and stood with her back to the glass, Lisbon glittering out behind her shoulder, and she waited.

The knock came at nine exactly. Three knocks, evenly spaced, unhurried. Not a bellhop's knock.

Ben's hand went to his wedding ring and turned it once, all the way around, and then he let go and put both hands flat on his knees.

Claire crossed the room. Her heels made no sound on the carpet — she'd taken them off an hour ago and put them back on, and now she walked barefoot and the carpet swallowed it. She checked the peephole. Her shoulders came down a fraction, and Ben understood that some part of her had been braced for the wrong face.

The door opened.

Marcus stood in the corridor light with his jacket still on — the same soft-shouldered jacket from the bar, collar up against the evening, and in the flat white of the hallway he looked different than he had under the amber lamps. Younger, maybe. Or just less like a song and more like a man. His dark brown eyes went to Claire first, and held, and something passed between them that was not quite a smile on either side.

"Mrs. Maguire," he said. His voice was the same low thing it had been at the piano, the one that had made her lean across the bar two nights running.

"Claire," she said. "In here, it's Claire."

"Claire." He said it carefully, like he was trying it for size. Then his eyes moved past her, found Ben in the chair, and he nodded — a small, courteous nod, the kind a man gives another man across a room where something has already been agreed. "Mr. Maguire."

"Ben." His voice came out level. He was grateful for that. "Come in."

Marcus stepped across the threshold, and Claire closed the door behind him, and the click of the latch was very loud in the room. He stood just inside it, hands loose at his sides, taking the place in — the bed, the chair, the two of them arranged around it like furniture in a room built for this. He didn't smirk. Ben had half expected him to smirk, had braced for it, and the absence of it did something to his chest he couldn't name.

"There's a paper," Claire said.

"I see it."

"We're going to read it. Out loud. Before anything." She looked at Ben. "Both of us agreed."

Marcus took off his jacket and folded it over the back of the desk chair, and underneath he was in the black turtleneck that hugged his lean frame, and the gold watch sat on his wrist where it had sat all those nights over the keys. Then he turned and gave Claire his whole attention, and it was total, that attention, the way a man gives it when he's decided the room has only one other person in it worth the trouble.

"Read it," he said.

She unfolded the paper. Her hands were steadier now that she had something to do with them. Ben watched her face rather than the page, because he knew the page — he'd read it over her shoulder that afternoon and added one line in his own hand at the bottom, and she'd looked at him for a long moment and then written her name under it.

"Rule one," Claire said. "Everything stops if anyone says stop. Any of the three of us. No explanations required, no questions asked after."

"Understood," Marcus said.

"Rule two. Nothing happens that Ben doesn't see. He stays in the room. If he leaves, we stop."

Marcus's eyes came to Ben, rested there. "You're staying."

"I'm staying," Ben said.

"Rule three." Claire's voice had found its rhythm now, the librarian's rhythm, the one she used to read to a hall of children and had never quite lost. "Nothing marks. Nothing that shows tomorrow. No — " she hesitated for the first time, and Ben saw her decide to say it plainly anyway — "no marks on my skin that anyone could see."

Marcus nodded slowly. "Nothing that shows."

"Rule four." She turned the page. "What happens in this room stays in this room. No one talks about it after. Not to each other, not to anyone else. If we pass each other in a lobby, we're strangers who nodded once."

"That's a hard one," Marcus said, and it wasn't a protest — it was the musician in him reading the note and finding it true. "But I'll keep it."

"Rule five." Claire stopped. The paper dipped a little in her hand. Ben knew this was the one she'd argued with him about, the one she'd said was too much, and the one he'd said was the whole point. She lifted her chin and read it in a flat, careful voice. "Ben doesn't touch. Not me, not himself. He watches. That's all he does tonight."

The room went quiet. Marcus looked at Ben for a long moment — longer than was comfortable, long enough that Ben felt the heat come up his neck — and then Marcus said, quietly, "That's his rule?"

"It's mine," Ben said.

"Then it's mine to keep," Marcus said. "I'll hold you to it."

Claire turned the paper over. The last line was in Ben's handwriting, blue ink, the letters a little cramped because he'd written it standing up in the business center with a bad pen.

"Rule six," she read. "'At any point, Claire can ask Ben to leave the room, and he will, without a word, and wait in the hall until she comes for him.'" She looked up from the page, and her green eyes were wet at the corners in a way that had nothing to do with crying. "You added that."

"I added that."

"Why."

"Because I don't want you doing this for me," Ben said. "I want you doing it for you. And I want you to know you can shut the door on me any time and I'll stand in the hall like a dog and not say one word about it."

Claire folded the paper along its creases, carefully, and set it down on the nightstand. The reading was finished. The paper lay there against the lamp's little pool of light, and nobody moved.

Marcus was still standing just inside the door, jacket off, hands loose, and he was — Ben noticed it now, in the silence, in the way he hadn't yet taken a single step toward the bed — quieter than he'd been at the piano. At the bar he'd had a whole room to play to, a room that wanted him, and he'd filled it without effort. Here there was no room. There was a woman and her husband and a chair, and Marcus stood in the middle of it like a man reading the first page of a book he wasn't sure he'd been given permission to open.

Claire stood by the nightstand with her hand resting on the folded paper, and she looked at Marcus, and Marcus looked at her, and Ben sat in his chair with his hands flat on his knees and understood, with a clarity that went through him like cold water, that watching was going to be a different thing entirely from having agreed to it in the dark of their anniversary night.

"Well," Marcus said at last, and his low voice was almost gentle. "Six rules."

"Six," Claire said.

"Then I'd like to know which one you're going to break first," he said, "so I know what kind of night this is going to be."

Claire's breath caught — Ben heard it, the small hitch of it — and then she laughed, low and surprised, the way she had in the bar when he'd said something clever, and it was the laugh that undid him every time. "None of them," she said.

"Good," Marcus said, and took his first step into the room.

He stopped in front of her, close — close enough that Ben could see the difference in their heights, the way she had to lift her chin. He didn't touch her. His hands stayed at his sides, and he looked down at her face for a long moment, and then his eyes went to the gold pendant at her throat and he said, "May I?"

"Yes," Claire said, and her voice was not quite steady, and Ben's hands closed on his own knees.

Marcus reached up and took the pendant between his thumb and forefinger, and turned it over once, the way Ben turned his ring. Then he let it fall back against her skin and his fingers went to the clasp at the nape of her neck. He found it without looking. He was looking at her face. The clasp opened, and the pendant slid down her chest and he caught it in his palm before it fell. He set it on the nightstand beside the folded paper, and Claire stood with her throat bare and her hair coming loose from its pins, and Ben found he had stopped breathing.

"Turn around," Marcus said.

She turned. The back of the black dress was closed with a long zip, and Marcus's fingers found the tab of it at the top of her spine and drew it down — slowly, one tooth at a time, the sound of it small and deliberate in the quiet room — all the way to the small of her back. His knuckles brushed the skin there as he went. Claire's shoulders rose and fell, once, and her head tipped forward a little, and Ben watched the pale line of her exposed back appear inch by inch in the lamplight, the little hollow at the base of her spine, the strap of her bra, and his mouth was dry.

"Step out of it," Marcus said.

She stepped out of the dress and it pooled around her ankles, and she stood in her bra and her knickers, barefoot on the hotel carpet, and she did not cover herself. Ben had seen her naked a thousand times in twelve years and he had never seen her quite like this — not because of what she was wearing, which was almost nothing, but because of how she stood. Straight-backed. Chin up. Her green eyes fixed on Marcus like she was daring him to be the one to look away.

Marcus didn't look away. He unhooked her bra with the same unhurried competence, one hand, and it came loose. She let it fall, and her breasts were in the lamplight, soft and full and a little flushed, her nipples drawn up tight. He looked at her a long moment and then he said, "Lie down on the bed. On your back."

She went. She lay down on the coverlet and her chestnut hair came loose from its coil and spread across the white pillow, and she bent one knee and then, after a moment, let it fall open. Her knickers were still on. Ben could see the dark shape of her through the pale fabric, and he could see that the fabric was already damp.

Marcus came to the bed and did not get on it yet. He stood at the foot of it and looked down at her, and his hands were on his own belt. He undid it and drew it out through the loops and set it aside without ceremony. Then he climbed onto the bed on his knees and put his hands on her thighs and pushed them wider apart, and Claire's breath went out of her in a rush.

"You're going to want to close your eyes," he said to her. "Don't. Look at your husband."

Her head turned on the pillow. Her green eyes found Ben in the chair. Ben looked back at her and could not have said what his own face was doing. Marcus hooked his fingers into the waistband of her knickers and drew them down her legs and off, and dropped them over the side of the bed, and then he lowered his head between her thighs.

Claire made a sound — not a word, a sound, low in her throat — and her eyes stayed on Ben for a moment and then they didn't, they slid off and away and her head pressed back into the pillow.

Marcus took his time. His mouth worked at her slowly, and from the chair Ben could see the long dark line of his back between her bent knees, and the way her hips lifted off the bed and then settled and then lifted again. His tongue went up the length of her, flat and slow, and Claire's hand came down and found his head and her fingers pushed into his short black hair and held on. The wet sound of it carried across the quiet room. Ben heard his wife's breath break into pieces.

"Oh," Claire said. "Oh — God — " and then she stopped trying to say anything at all.

Marcus's hand came up and his fingers spread her open, and his tongue found her clit and stayed there, and Claire's whole body arched off the bed and her heel dug into the coverlet. He worked her with his tongue in a rhythm that was not fast and was not slow but was relentless, and Ben watched his wife's face come apart by degrees, her mouth open, her eyes squeezed shut and then snapping open again to find him in the chair, and there was something in her face when she found him there that Ben would think about for the rest of his life.

"Ben," she said. "Ben — ". Then she couldn't finish it, and her hips were moving against Marcus's mouth now, shameless, and Marcus's hands held her thighs wide and took it, and the wet sound of it was the loudest thing in the room.

She came with her hand fisted in the coverlet and her back bowed and a sound that was almost a sob. Marcus didn't stop. He went on licking her, softer now, drawing it out, and Claire's thighs shook and closed around his head. He let them, and his hands came up to hold them there, and Ben sat in his chair with his cock aching against his trousers and his hands flat on his knees and did not touch himself, because it was the rule, because it was the whole point.

When Marcus lifted his head at last his mouth was wet and his dark eyes were bright, and he wiped his face with the back of his wrist and looked over at Ben. "She's ready," he said. "You want to watch her take it?"

"Yes," Ben said. His voice came out rough. "Watch her take it."

Marcus pulled his turtleneck over his head and dropped it off the side of the bed, and his chest was lean and dark in the lamplight, and there was a small scar at his collarbone that Ben would wonder about later and never ask. He got his trousers down and kicked them away, and his cock came free of his shorts, thick and dark and already wet at the tip, and Claire looked at it and then looked at Ben and her mouth was open and her chest was heaving. She looked — she looked like a woman who had surprised herself.

"Claire," Marcus said, and his low voice had gone lower. "Look at me."

She looked. He knelt between her thighs and took himself in his hand and dragged the head of his cock up through her, once, through the wet, and Claire's hips jerked and her mouth fell open. Then he pushed into her.

He went slowly. Ben watched her take him — watched her cunt stretch around him, watched her whole body take the shape of him inch by inch, and Claire's hands came up and gripped the pillow on either side of her head. She made a sound that was not a word. Marcus stopped when he was all the way in, and held there, and his head dropped forward and his shoulders were shaking with the effort of holding still.

"Fuck," Marcus said, very quietly, to no one. "Fuck."

"Move," Claire said. "Marcus — move — " and he did.

He fucked her slowly at first, long strokes, pulling almost all the way out and pushing back in, and every time he pushed in Claire's breath broke and her hands tightened on the pillow. The bed creaked. The wet sound of it was unmistakable, the sound of her, slick and open and taking him. Ben watched Marcus's dark hands on his wife's pale hips, watched the way Marcus pulled her onto him as he thrust, watched Claire's breasts move with the rhythm of it.

"Harder," Claire said, and it came out of her like something torn loose. "Please — harder — "

Marcus gave it to her. He drove into her and the bed knocked against the wall and Claire cried out — a real cry, high and startled — and her hand flew to her own mouth and then away again. She was panting, and Marcus was breathing hard through his nose, and the slap of his body against hers was steady and loud in the small room.

"Look at him," Marcus said, driving into her. "Look at your husband watching you take this cock. Tell him what it feels like."

Claire's head turned on the pillow. Her eyes found Ben in the chair and held — her face flushed and her hair wild and her mouth open. She said, between the thrusts, in a voice that was not quite her own, "It feels — Ben — it feels so — ". Then she couldn't finish it, and her eyes rolled up and her back arched. She came again, clenching around him, and Marcus groaned through his teeth and fucked her through it, and Ben sat in his chair and watched his wife come apart on another man's cock and his own hands were fists on his knees. He had never been so hard or so still in his life.

Marcus pulled out and turned her over. "On your front," he said. "Knees."

Claire went up onto her hands and knees and Marcus pushed into her from behind. She dropped her head and moaned into the pillow, and now Ben could see Marcus's face, see the sweat on his dark skin and the way his jaw was set, the way he was losing the last of his control. He fucked her faster, one hand on her hip, the other flat on the small of her back, and Claire's shoulders were shaking and her fingers were twisted in the coverlet. She was saying something into the pillow that Ben couldn't hear and didn't need to.

"I'm close," Marcus said, and his voice was ragged. "Where do you want it."

Claire turned her face on the pillow. Her eyes found Ben. "Ben," she said. "Tell him."

It was the rule. It was the whole point. Ben sat in his chair with his cock straining and his hands flat on his knees and his voice came out of him low and certain. It did not shake. "Inside her," he said. "Come inside my wife."

Marcus drove into her and held, and Ben watched his body go rigid and the muscles of his back stand out, and Marcus made a sound that was almost angry, and Ben watched him empty himself into her, pulse after pulse, his hands gripping her hips hard enough to bruise and then loosening at the last, and Claire's head dropped and her whole body shuddered. She made a small broken sound into the pillow.

Then it was quiet. Marcus pulled out slowly and Claire gasped, and he came down off the bed on unsteady legs and stood there a moment with his back to them, breathing. Claire rolled onto her side and drew her knees up, and Ben could see it — could see what Marcus had left in her, the wet of it on her thigh — and his chest ached with something that was not jealousy and was not pride and had no name he could find.

Marcus turned around. He looked at Ben in the chair, and there was something careful in his face now, the musician come back after the storm. "Six rules," he said. "I kept them."

"You kept them," Ben said.

Claire pushed herself up on one elbow, and her hair was a mess and her face was flushed and her green eyes were bright and wet, and she looked from Marcus to Ben and back, and she said, in a voice that was hoarse and quiet and entirely her own, "Nobody said anything about a seventh."

Marcus picked up his turtleneck from the floor and held it, not putting it on yet. "What would the seventh be," he said.

Claire looked at Ben. The question was not for Marcus. It sat in the room between the two of them, and the folded paper lay on the nightstand beside her gold pendant, and the bed was wrecked, and Ben understood that whatever he said next was going to be the shape of the rest of it.

"Ask me tomorrow," he said.

Comments

Be the first to share your thoughts on this chapter.