The Doorbell
The Overflow of Ink · Chapter 3 of 5

The Doorbell

Carol pulls on her sweatpants and opens the door to Diane, who stands in the hallway with a bottle of wine and a sharp look that takes in the ruined kitchen, the towel, and Oliver at the table. Diane steps inside, sets the wine down, and walks past Carol to stand over Oliver, her eyes on the blank page. 'You haven't written a word,' she says, and before he can answer she drops to her knees under the table, unzips his shorts, and takes his cock into her mouth while Carol watches from the sink. The act this chapter delivers: Diane sucks Oliver's cock under Carol's kitchen table, her mouth working him until he comes on her tongue, and she swallows and looks up at him with a challenge in her eyes.

Carol didn't move right away. She stood at the sink with the towel hanging off her hand, and Oliver watched her decide something — her jaw working, her eyes going from the door to him and back — and then she bent, hooked her sweatpants off the floor with one finger, and stepped into them. No underwear. He noticed that the way he noticed everything, automatically, filing it away for later. The drawstring she didn't bother with. The waistband sat loose on her hips and left a stripe of belly bare.

"Well," she said, and the word had a laugh buried in it somewhere. "Here we go."

She crossed the kitchen, and the floorboards gave under her, and she pulled the door open with the towel still in her other hand like a flag she'd forgotten she was holding.

Diane stood in the hallway under the yellow bulb. She had a bottle of red by the neck, and her coat was open, and her auburn hair was down out of whatever severe thing she usually did with it — loose around her shoulders, a little wild, as though she'd spent the walk over arguing with herself and lost. Her eyes went past Carol's face and traveled the room in a single unhurried sweep: the pan on the stove with its blackened edges, the two plates still on the counter, the towel, the sweatpants, the sweat on Carol's collarbone. Then they found Oliver at the table and stopped.

"You haven't written a word," she said.

Oliver's hand was still flat on the blank page. He took it off, slowly, as though he'd been caught at something worse than not writing.

"I've written it in my head," he said.

"Oh, in your head." Diane stepped through the door and Carol had to move back to let her. "That's where all the great ones live, isn't it. In somebody's head." She set the wine down on the counter — the bottle met the laminate with a hard little clink that was the only sound in the room after the door swung shut — and she didn't look at Carol at all. "Glasses?"

"Cabinet. Left of the sink." Carol's voice had gone careful. Oliver heard it and knew she was doing the same thing he was: watching Diane the way you watch weather come across a field.

Diane didn't get the glasses. She walked past the sink, past Carol, and her heels made a slow deliberate rhythm on the tile, and she came around the table and stood over Oliver with her arms folded and her eyes down on Mina's page propped against the salt shaker, on the pen lying across the empty white.

"That's hers," she said. "The line."

"Yes."

"Read it to me."

"You've read it. You were there."

"I want to hear you say it." Her green eyes came up then, and there was something in them that wasn't contempt, though it was wearing contempt's coat. "Out loud. In your voice. Because I've been thinking about it all the way across town and I want to know if it sounds as filthy in your mouth as it did in mine."

The lamp threw her shadow across the table and up the wall, long and thin. Oliver felt the heat come up his neck. He picked up the page. The crease was soft now from handling, and the corner had dried stiff.

"I want you to hold my hair back," he read, and his voice cracked on the second word. He cleared his throat and went on, quieter, "and tell me what a good little writer I am while you fuck my mouth."

The room was very still. Somewhere down the block a car door slammed and a dog answered it.

"Hm," Diane said. That sound she made, the one that came before she cut something open. "And what did you do with it?"

"I don't know yet."

"No. You don't." She uncrossed her arms and set one hand flat on the table and leaned on it and looked at him, and the crimson of her blouse caught the lamplight and made her skin look pale and hot at once. "You know what your problem is, Oliver? You're a nice boy. Nice boys write about collarbones. They write about the light on a woman's shoulder and they think they've done something." She straightened. "You want to know what a woman actually wants in her mouth?"

He couldn't answer that. His throat had gone dry as paper.

"Move your chair back," she said.

"Diane—" Carol started, from the sink, and there was something in her voice — not a warning, exactly. A question.

"He's got a deadline and a blank page," Diane said, without turning. "I'm going to help him understand the assignment."

Oliver pushed the chair back. The legs scraped and he winced at the sound. Diane came around the corner of the table and dropped — not gracefully, not with any ceremony at all, her knees hitting the tile hard enough that he heard it — and she was under the table, under the lamp's angled light, her auburn hair pooling against the wood of the chair, and her red-nailed hands were already at his shorts.

"Lift," she said, and he lifted. She had the button undone and the zipper down and her hand inside, and her fingers closed around his cock through the cotton of his boxers. She made a sound — a small, involuntary thing, not quite a laugh — and her eyes came up to his.

"Well," she said. "Mina wasn't exaggerating."

"She—" Oliver's voice came out strangled. "Mina talked about—"

"Mina writes everything down, darling. Didn't you notice." Diane pulled him free of the boxers and the cool air of the kitchen crossed his cock and then her breath was on it, warm, close, and she looked at it the way she looked at a manuscript she intended to improve. "You're going to want to put your hands somewhere," she said. "Put one in my hair. That's what it's for."

He put his hand in her hair. It was softer than he expected, warm from the hallway. She made an approving noise and then her mouth came down on him and his hand clenched.

She didn't start slow. She took him in — the whole head, her lips stretched around it, her tongue flat and hot against the underside. Then she sank down, and down, her throat opening, and Oliver's head went back and hit the top rail of the chair. He heard himself say something that wasn't a word. The wet heat of her mouth was a shock all the way up his spine. Her tongue worked the vein along the bottom, found the ridge under the head, and pressed, and his hips jerked up before he could stop them.

She pulled off with a wet sound. "Don't fuck my throat without asking," she said, and her lips were slick. She was smiling, and the smile was the first honest thing he'd seen on her face all evening. "Ask nicely."

"Please," he said. It came out wrecked. "Please, can I—"

"Can you what? Say it."

"Can I fuck your throat."

"Mm." She dragged her tongue up the length of him, slow, deliberate, and the flat of it left a wet stripe that caught the lamplight. "Since you asked so pretty." And she took him again, deeper than before, her jaw working, and Oliver got his other hand into her hair and held her — not pushing, just holding, the weight of her skull in his palms. She hummed around him, and the hum went through his cock like a struck bell.

Across the room Carol had not moved from the sink. He couldn't see her face. But he could hear her breathing, and it had changed, and he could hear the towel in her hand being wrung, the wet twist of it, and it was the loudest thing in the room besides Diane's mouth.

"Look at me," Diane said, pulling off just far enough to speak, her hand still working him, slick and fast. "I want you to watch what a woman who's been told her whole life she's too sharp does when she finally gets to be useful."

"You're—" He couldn't get the sentence out. She took him again and the words dissolved. His glasses had fogged. He took them off one-handed and set them down blind on the table and the world went soft at the edges. He watched her through it — the auburn of her hair moving, her shoulders working under the crimson, her hand braced on his knee with the nails dug in. The wet sound of her mouth was obscene and specific and it was the only sound he could hear over his own pulse.

Then she did something with her tongue — a curl, a press into the spot just under the head — and his whole body tightened. "Diane," he said, and her name came out like a warning, and she didn't stop. She looked up at him and held his eyes and she did it again, harder, and her hand closed around the base of him and squeezed, and that was it.

"I'm going to—"

She pulled off, her lips still on the head of his cock, her hand working him fast and tight, and she said, muffled and fierce and looking straight up at him, "Give it to me. All of it. On my tongue."

He came with a sound he'd never made before, his hips lifting off the chair, his hand knotted in her hair. She took it — every pulse of it, her mouth hot and open and her tongue moving to catch it. He felt the last of it spill and her throat work as she swallowed, and then again, and the wet clench of her mouth around the softening head of his cock was almost too much. He said so, and she let him go and sat back on her heels.

The kitchen was quiet. The lamp hummed. Rosemary and olive oil and the salt of her mouth and something else, something animal, hung in the warm air.

Diane wiped the corner of her lip with her thumb and looked at it, and then at him. Her eyes were bright and her cheeks were flushed and her hair was a wreck, and she was not smiling anymore. She looked, for one unguarded second, like a woman who had surprised herself.

"There," she said, and her voice had a rasp in it now, the first crack in the lacquer. "Now go write page two."

Oliver didn't reach for the pen. His hands were still shaking, and the page was a white square on the table, and the pen lay across it at an angle, and he looked at the two of them instead — Diane on her heels with her skirt rucked up around her thighs and one red thumbnail still pressed to her lip, Carol at the sink with the towel twisted into a rope in both fists.

"You're both just going to stand there," he said. His voice came out low and scraped. "Watching me not write."

"I'm not standing," Diane said. "I'm kneeling. There's a difference, and the difference is my knees." She got up in stages, one hand on the chair rail, and when she was upright she tugged her skirt down and smoothed it with her palms, and the gesture was so ordinary, so much a woman fixing herself after a meeting, that Oliver laughed — one short breath of it — before he could stop himself. Her eyes flicked to him. "Something funny?"

"No. Yes. You just — you swallowed me and now you're fixing your skirt like you're about to chair a panel."

"That's how it's done, darling." She picked up the wine bottle and turned it in her hands and set it down again, and for the first time her fingers weren't quite steady on it. "A woman does a thing and then she does the next thing. She doesn't sit on the floor being moved about it."

Carol's towel hit the counter with a wet slap. "You are moved about it," she said. "You've been moved about it since the conference room. You couldn't get out of your own way fast enough."

Diane turned, slowly, and the lamplight caught the hollow under her cheekbone. "Say that again."

"I said you wanted it. You wanted it so bad you couldn't stand that he got it from me first, and now you're down on the tile with your mouth full and you still can't stand it." Carol's chin came up. The towel was dripping onto the counter and she didn't look at it. "You think I don't know that look? I've had it on my own face."

The room held its breath. Diane's hand found the back of the chair — Oliver's chair, the one he was still sitting in — and her nails clicked on the wood. Then she laughed, and it was a real laugh, tired and cracked and nothing like the ones she used in meetings.

"God," she said. "You're a nasty little thing under all that sunshine. Fine. Yes. I wanted it." She looked down at Oliver, and the flush had climbed all the way to her ears now, and she let him see it. "I've been writing about cocks for six years and I hadn't had one in my mouth in three. There. Is that enough truth for the collection, or do you want me to type it up for you?"

Oliver reached for the pen. He didn't think about it, didn't plan it; his hand just moved, and the cheap plastic was cool and light and familiar, and he wrote in the margin of Mina's page, in his small cramped hand, three words.

Diane leaned over to read them. Her hair swung forward and brushed the paper. "What is that. 'She wanted it.' That's not a story. That's a shrug."

"It's not the story," he said. "It's the note. The architect gets to the door and he doesn't know whether she'll open it, and he thinks it's about the wine, or the way she looks at him, or whether he's good enough — and it's none of that. It's that she wanted it, and she's been sitting in her car outside her own house for twenty minutes working up to admitting it." He heard his own voice go quiet and steady, the way it did when the thing was right. "That's page two. The wanting. Before anybody touches anybody."

Diane straightened. She looked at the three words for a long moment, and then at him, and her mouth did something complicated.

"You wrote that down," she said. "Just now. With your cock still wet and your knees in the shape of a chair."

"I write in the margins first. Always have."

"Huh." She pulled the other chair out — the one with the short leg — and sat down in it, and it wobbled, and she didn't correct it. "Then write the next line in the margin, nice boy. Write me the part where she admits it. Out loud. To his face. And make her mean it."

Carol came away from the sink at last, the towel abandoned, and pulled out the third chair, and the three of them sat around the scarred table under the one lamp with the wine still corked and the pan still black on the stove, and Oliver bent his head over the page and began to write the second sentence of the story, and the pen scratched, and nobody said anything at all.

The pen stopped.

It had made it four words down the page — The architect stood in — and then Oliver's hand went still, and the scratch of the nib died, and the kitchen filled back up with its little sounds: the lamp, the fridge, a car going by out on the street with its bass turned up so loud the window glass buzzed in its frame.

He looked at the line he'd written. Then he looked at Mina's torn page, propped against the salt shaker, the crease soft from all the handling.

Four words. He'd written four words, and they were the wrong four, and he knew it the way you know a bad chord.

"It's not working," he said.

Diane's wine glass — she'd found one after all, and filled it nearly to the rim — came down on the table with a clink. "It's been ninety seconds."

"It's been ninety seconds and I've already lied twice." Oliver set the pen down and pushed the page away from himself, and then, because that felt like giving up, pulled it back. "The architect stood in. He doesn't stand in anything. He's not a man who stands in doorways. I made him up so I wouldn't have to look at what Mina wrote."

Carol had her elbows on the table and her chin in her hands, and her honey-blond hair had come loose from behind her ears on one side and hung down over her wrist. "So look at it," she said.

"I have looked at it. I've looked at it so many times the words have gone stupid." He picked up the torn page. The corner where it had ripped out of Mina's notepad was furred, and there was a coffee ring on the back of it, and the ink was Mina's small square hand, pressed hard enough that he could feel the letters under his thumb like braille. "That's the problem. It's not mine. It's a line somebody said and I'm supposed to build a house around it, and every time I read it I hear it in her voice instead of—"

He stopped.

Diane's fingers were on the stem of her glass and her eyes were on him, and Carol had lifted her chin off her hands.

"Instead of what," Diane said.

"Instead of out loud. In the room. Where it could do something." Oliver turned the page around and laid it flat in the middle of the table, between the three of them, and smoothed the crease with the heel of his hand. "That's what's wrong with all of it. Harry was right and I didn't want to hear it. It's a story about a woman who wants something, written by a boy who's been reading it off the page like a shopping list."

The lamp hummed. Carol's bare foot found the rung of her chair and curled around it.

"So read it to us," she said. "Not to yourself. To us. And don't do the voice you did before — the one where you go all quiet and apologetic like you're reading a eulogy."

"That's the only voice I've got."

"Then get another one," Diane said. "You've had your cock in my throat tonight and you can't find a second voice. God help the collection."

Oliver laughed — just a breath of it, but it loosened something in his chest. He picked up the page and held it at both edges and sat back in the chair, and the short leg of Diane's chair was still wobbling on the tile because she'd set her heel down wrong, and the sound of it was oddly steadying, a metronome for a man about to do something stupid.

He read.

" I want you to hold my hair back and tell me what a good little writer I am while you fuck my mouth. "

Steady. Not the eulogy voice. He read it the way a man reads a line he's decided to believe, and the words came out of him and sat in the air over the table and didn't go anywhere, and he watched what they did to the two women across from him.

Carol's foot slid off the rung of the chair. She didn't put it back.

Diane's glass stopped halfway to her mouth and stayed there, and her green eyes had gone dark and flat and very still, the way water goes still before something breaks the surface of it.

He read it again.

The third time, he didn't read it off the paper. He laid Mina's page down flat and lifted his eyes and said it to them from memory, and his voice did something on the word mouth — dropped, softened, went somewhere private and sure — and it landed in the kitchen like a coin on a countertop.

Carol made a small sound. Not a word. Her hand had come up and closed around the loose fall of her hair on the left side, the way she pulled it back when she was working, and she caught herself doing it and let go, and the hair slid forward again over her shoulder.

Diane set the wine down. All the way down, no sip, and her red nails stayed on the glass a moment after it touched the wood, and the lamp caught the polish and made five little wet-looking lights across the back of her hand.

"Say it again," she said, "and this time don't say it to the room."

Oliver's thumb was on the furred edge of the torn page. He could feel his own pulse under it. She's testing me — that was the first thought, quick and defensive, the one that wanted to make this about her. The second thought, the truer one, came slower and settled lower: no. She wants to hear what it sounds like when it's aimed.

He turned his head. Not to Diane. To Carol.

" I want you to hold my hair back, " he said, " and tell me what a good little writer I am while you fuck my mouth. "

Carol's freckles stood out against her cheeks the way they did when she blushed, pale and sudden, and she didn't laugh it off, didn't tuck her hair, didn't do any of the things she did when she was covering. She sat there with her elbows on the scarred wood and looked at him across the salt shaker and the propped page, and her throat moved when she swallowed, and then she said, quiet, "That's not a line. That's a want."

"I know."

"Whose?"

Oliver put his hand flat on the table, fingers spread, and felt the burn mark under his palm — the little comma of scar in the wood — and the answer came up out of him before he'd finished arranging it. "Mine. Both of yours. It doesn't matter who said it first. It's the thing under all six stories, and Harry could smell it on the pages and it made him sick, because we've been writing around it like it's a hole in the floor." He looked at Diane. "You know what I mean. You write the filthiest ones and you still write around it. You put a woman in a room and you give her a reason to be there that isn't the real one."

Diane's jaw worked. For a second he thought he'd gone too far — the auburn hair, the sharp cheekbone, the flat green stare, all of it aimed at him like a held breath before a slap.

Then she laughed. One short, ugly, honest note of it, nothing like the theatrical sighs she'd been feeding the office all week.

"Fine," she said. "Yes. Fine. I give her a dead husband or a business trip or a rainy night so nobody has to say the plain thing." Her fingers found the stem of the glass again, and she didn't lift it. "And the plain thing is that she wants to be used like a toy and told she's good at it. Go on. Say what you're going to do with that."

"I want to write it out loud first." Oliver pulled the page back toward himself, and the pen with it, and the nib hovered. "Not the story. The want. Before I put a single verb down, I want to hear it said in this room by somebody who means it, so that when I write it I'm not guessing at the sound."

Carol's bare foot came back up and found the rung of her chair, and then, deliberate, slid off again.

"Then ask," she said.

He did. He set the pen down and folded his hands on the table like a man at an interview, and he asked, and his voice was steady and his hands were not, and the lamp hummed over all three of them.

"That's you," he said. "Both of you. That's what I want to write. Say it back to me."

Diane leaned forward. The crimson blouse pulled tight across her shoulders and the lamp threw her shadow up the kitchen wall behind her, and her red mouth curved around something that wasn't quite a smile.

"Then write it," she said. "Write me saying it back."

Oliver didn't reach for the pen.

That was the thing he noticed about himself, sitting there with his folded hands on the scarred wood — that every other man he'd ever imagined being would have reached for the pen. Would have said yes ma'am and put the nib down and written it out, because the ask was on the table and the ask was the easy part. But the ask wasn't the ask. The ask was a test dressed up in a red blouse, and the answer to a test was never the fast yes.

"No," he said.

Diane's eyebrow went up. It was the slow kind, the kind that had a whole paragraph of contempt folded into it. "No."

"Not like that." Oliver turned the torn page a quarter turn, so the coffee ring on the back of it caught the lamplight and showed itself. "You said write you saying it back. If I write it down right now, I'm transcribing. I'm a clerk. And you'll read it tomorrow and you'll hear your own voice in it and you'll know I just copied down what you handed me." He looked at her. "You want to be written, or you want to be heard?"

Diane's mouth did something complicated. Her nails tapped once against the stem of the glass, and then stopped, and she sat back in her chair and the short leg of it knocked on the tile and she let it.

"That's a very pretty distinction for a man with a blank page in front of him," she said.

"It's the only distinction I've got." He picked up the pen then — not to write, just to hold it, to have something in his hand that wasn't the edge of the table. The ink was already dry on the nib. "Mina wrote her line because she meant it. That's why it's got teeth. If I write yours because you dared me to, it'll be a dare. It'll read like a dare. Harry will smell it through the envelope."

Carol made a sound — half a laugh, half something else — and when he looked at her she had her chin propped on her knuckles and her blue eyes moving between the two of them like she was watching a tennis match and had money on it. "He's right," she said. "God, he's annoying when he's right."

Diane turned her head slowly. "You're taking his side."

"I'm taking the side of not writing another dead-husband story." Carol's bare toe found the rung of her chair again and this time she kept it there. "You know what your last one was? The one Harry hated? The widow on the ferry. She had a dead husband and a business trip. She had a dead husband who was on a business trip." She shrugged, and the strap of her sundress slipped a half inch down her shoulder and she didn't fix it. "It was beautiful. It was the best thing in the stack and it didn't get me wet once."

The kitchen went quiet in a way that had texture to it. The fridge kicked off. The lamp hummed. Somewhere in the building a door closed and the whole apartment seemed to lean toward the sound and then forget it.

Diane's green eyes had gone flat and bright at once, and Oliver watched her decide — watched the pride come up in her like water finding a crack, and then watched her do the thing he hadn't expected, which was to pick up her wine and drink from it, deep, and set it down empty.

"Fine," she said. "Then hear me."

She pushed her chair back. The short leg scraped and she didn't care about that either, and she stood up and came around the corner of the table with her heels ticking on the tile, and she stopped at Oliver's shoulder and looked down at him with her auburn hair falling forward off her cheek and her mouth still curved around that almost-smile.

"You want to hear it said by somebody who means it," she said. "So don't write. Listen. And when you write it later, write the way I say it and not the way you'd say it, because you'd say it nice and I'm not going to say it nice."

Oliver set the pen down. His hands had gone steady, which surprised him — the way his hands only ever went steady right before the thing that should have made them shake.

"I'm listening."

Diane didn't sit back down. She stood at his shoulder with her hip against the table's edge and one hand flat on the scarred wood, and the way she was standing put her blouse at his eye level, the crimson going dark where the lamplight fell off into shadow, and she smelled like wine and something sharp underneath it, something like citrus peel.

"Then listen," she said. "And don't you dare look at the paper while I say it."

Oliver put his hands in his lap. It took an act of will he could feel in his shoulders.

Diane's voice was not the voice she used in meetings. It was lower, and it had gravel in it, and it came out of her with a contempt that had curdled into something else entirely — the sound of a woman who had spent years writing desire in the third person and was discovering, at thirty-four, that the first person cost more.

"I don't want a story," she said. "I want a man who knows what I am and doesn't flinch from it, and then I want him to put his hand in my hair and use my mouth until I can't think, and I want to hear him say I'm good at it. Not sweet. Not beautiful. Good. Like a thing that's been trained and does what it's for." Her nails pressed white into the tabletop, and then she lifted her hand and turned her head and looked straight down at him. "Now. Was that plain enough for you, or do I need to say it slower?"

The fridge hummed. Carol had gone very still, her foot still hooked on the rung, and she was watching Diane with an expression Oliver couldn't read — not shock. Something more like recognition.

"That's not the line," Oliver said, and his voice came out rough. "That's better than the line. The line's a sentence. That's a person." He reached for the pen without looking at it, found it, and then didn't write. "Say the last part again. The good part."

"You heard it."

"I heard it. I want to hear it in my own ear, not through the room. Say it to me."

Diane's jaw tightened. For a heartbeat the old Diane was back, the one who sighed at other people's sentences, and then she let that go the way you let go of a rope you've been holding too long, and she crouched down beside his chair so her face was level with his, and the auburn hair swung forward and she didn't push it back.

"Tell me I'm good at it," she said, quiet, precise, every word placed like a chess piece. "Tell me I'm good at it while you fuck my mouth. That's what I want. I've wanted it since I was twenty-two and too proud to say so, and I have written it into eleven different women and never once put it in my own mouth." She held his eyes. "There. Now it's in the room. Do something with it."

Oliver's throat had gone dry. He was aware, with a clarity that felt almost clinical, of the three of them breathing in the small kitchen, of the lamp's heat on the top of his head, of the torn page under his elbow and the pen still in his hand and the fact that he had not written a single word of the thing he'd been hired to write.

"Carol," he said. "You too. Your turn. Not the line — yours. Something you'd never put in a story because it's too close to the bone."

Carol pulled her foot off the rung and set it flat on the floor and sat up straight, and the sundress strap was still down off her shoulder and she left it there. Her freckles had faded back into her cheeks. She looked younger than twenty-three for a second, and then she didn't.

"I want to be the one who's chosen," she said. "Not the one who's there. Not the one who's convenient." She turned her glass a quarter turn on the table, the same quarter turn he'd given the page, and her mouth was steady and her eyes were not. "Every man I've ever been with, I was the girl in the room. The one who was around. And I want somebody to look at a whole room full of people and pick me and be stupid about it. Make a scene about it. Ruin something." She shrugged, and it wasn't casual at all. "That's the thing I don't write. Because in the stories the woman's always picked for a reason. The reason's always her tits or her mouth or her being in the right place at the right time. And I want to be picked for no reason. Just picked."

Oliver sat with that. The pen was warm in his hand now, and he could feel the shape of the story beginning to assemble itself behind his eyes — not the architect, not the widow, but the two of them, Diane's gravel and Carol's steady mouth, and the plain thing under both.

"All right," he said. "I've got it. Both of you, listen, because I'm only going to say this once and then I'm going to write it, and if I stop to explain myself we'll lose it." He turned the page over — the blank side, the coffee ring on the other face pressed invisible against the wood — and set the nib down. "The story's a woman who's been in the room a long time. She's good at her job. She's the one who's always around. And one night the man she's been watching — the quiet one, the one nobody picks — looks up and picks her. Not for a reason. For her. And she doesn't know what to do with it, because she's spent her whole life being convenient, so she does the only thing she knows how to do with a want that big, which is get on her knees and give him her mouth and make him tell her she's good at it."

Diane made a sound. Not a laugh. Something lower.

"That's the widow and the ferry and the business trip all over again," she said, "except you've taken out the husband and put in the wanting."

"That's the whole point." Oliver wrote a line, and then another, and the nib scratched and the ink went down dark and sure, and he didn't stop to admire it. "Harry said he could smell it. What he smelled was us writing about people who want things for reasons. Nobody in this office wants anything for a reason. We want it because we want it, and we've been dressing it up in dead husbands for years."

Carol leaned in over the table, and her hair fell forward and swung, and she read the two lines upside down and her lips moved around the words. "It's got teeth," she said. "It's got your teeth in it."

"It's got both of yours." He wrote a third line, and then the pen stopped again, and he looked up. "Diane. The good at it line. I'm going to put it in her mouth, and I'm going to put it in his mouth too, and I need to know — when she says it, does she mean it, or is she saying it to make him say it back?"

Diane's green eyes came up slowly. "Both," she said. "That's the whole woman. She means it and she's fishing, and she'd die before she admitted which is which."

Oliver wrote it down. The kitchen had gone quiet in a different way now — not the held-breath quiet of a test, but the working quiet, the quiet of three people bent over the same sheet of paper. Carol had her chin on her fist. Diane had come around to read over his shoulder, and her hair brushed his ear when she leaned in, and neither of them moved away from it.

His left hand was in his lap, and it had been in his lap for a while, and it moved before he'd decided to move it.

Diane's knee was right there. She'd come around the table to read over his shoulder and she hadn't gone back to her chair, so she was standing with her hip against the table's edge and her weight on her left leg, and her skirt hung down past her knee in a soft gray fold, and the fold was where his fingers went first — the back of his knuckles brushing the wool, feeling the warmth of her through it.

She didn't stop talking. That was the thing. She was saying something about the woman's voice, about how she'd never let a woman like this say "please" in the first paragraph, that it had to be earned — and Oliver wasn't listening to the words anymore, he was listening to the sound of them, and under the sound of them he was moving his hand.

Under the hem. The wool gave and then he was past it and there was the inside of her knee, the skin there gone soft and cool from the air in the kitchen, and just above it the heat started like a stove coming on.

Her sentence stopped.

Not with a period. It stopped in the middle, on the word "because," and the kitchen's working quiet snapped shut around the gap where her voice had been.

Oliver kept his eyes on the page. He could feel Carol's gaze come up from across the table — he could feel it the way you feel a light turned on — and he did not look at her, and he did not look at Diane, and his hand kept going up, slow, the way you'd read a line of your own prose you weren't sure about.

"Because," Diane said, and her voice had a catch in it now, a little hinge where the words turned, "because a woman like that doesn't —"

His fingertips found the edge of her underwear. Not the elastic at the hip, the other edge, the one that ran down between her legs, and the cloth there was thin and it was not dry.

She breathed out through her nose, hard, and her hand came down flat on the table beside his page and her nails made a sound on the wood.

"Oliver," she said.

"Mm." He turned his head just enough to look up at her, and her face was close — her hair falling forward off her cheek, her mouth slightly open, her green eyes very wide and very still. "You were saying. About the first paragraph."

"I was —" Her tongue came out and touched her lower lip and went back in. "I was saying she wouldn't say please until —"

He pressed.

Two fingers, flat, the cloth of her underwear between them and her. He felt the shape of her under it — the seam of her, the wet heat of it coming through the cotton like heat through a windowpane — and Diane's whole body went still against his hand. Then her hips moved. One small helpless roll of them forward, into the pressure, before she caught it and stopped herself.

"Until what," Oliver said.

Carol's chair creaked. He heard her shift, heard her set her glass down, and he still didn't look at her, and the not-looking was its own kind of heat, a wire strung taut between the two women with him in the middle of it.

"Until he's earned it," Diane said, and her voice had gone low and rough, and she said it fast, like a woman running across a road. "Until he's — Christ — until he's put his hand on her and made her forget the word —"

He moved his fingers in a slow circle and her sentence died again.

Her forehead came down. It touched his temple, her hair spilling over his ear and the side of his face, and he could smell her now at this distance — wine and citrus peel and underneath it something warmer, something that had been sitting under the citrus all evening and was rising now.

"You're going to make a mess of my skirt," she said against his ear. Not a complaint. Her breath was hot and it moved the hair at his temple.

"I haven't touched your skirt."

"You're going to."

"Am I."

He pushed the cloth aside with his thumb. It was a small movement, an easy one. It opened her to him the way a page opens, and the first bare touch of his fingers on her — slick, and hot, and startlingly soft after all that thin dry cotton — made Diane's breath go out of her in a rush that he felt on his cheek.

"Oh," she said. Just that. A small, undefended syllable, nothing like her.

Across the table Carol was completely silent, and Oliver knew without looking that her elbows were on the wood and her chin was on her hands and her eyes were doing the thing they did when she was taking notes.

He found her. Slid two fingers down through the wet and up again, and Diane's thigh came open under his hand — not a lot, an inch, the smallest surrender — and her knee pressed against the inside of his wrist.

"There," she said, and then, catching herself, "don't — don't you dare tell me I'm wet."

"I wasn't going to tell you anything." He circled the place that made her breath change, the small swollen knot of it, and her hip twitched against the table. "You already know."

"I know I've been —" She stopped. Her hand found his shoulder and her fingers dug in through his shirt, and the crimson of her cuff was at the corner of his eye. "I've been sitting in your ear for an hour with my legs crossed and my — God."

"Say it."

"No."

He took his fingers away.

Diane made a sound like a woman missing a step in the dark. Her hips followed his hand, a half-inch, and then she caught her own weight on the table and her nails scraped the wood and she said, "You absolute little —"

"Say it and I'll put them back."

Her breath came in and out of her nose, twice, hard. He could see her jaw working from the corner of his eye. The lamp hummed. Carol had not moved. The wine bottle sat on the counter with the lamplight in its shoulder, and somewhere out on the street a car went by slow, and the whole kitchen seemed to lean on the silence.

"I've been wet since you read it the third time," Diane said, and her voice cracked on "wet," and she pushed the words out flat and fast like a woman paying a debt. "Since you said it to her and not to the room. There. Are you satisfied, or do you want it in writing?"

"In writing, eventually." His fingers came back and found her, and she let out a sound that was almost a sob and bit it off. "That's what we're here for."

She was so wet now that the sound of it was audible in the small kitchen, a soft slick rhythm that had no business being as loud as it was, and Oliver felt his own cock stir against the inside of his shorts — the same shorts Diane had pulled him out of ten minutes ago, still unbuttoned, the waistband loose. He let that be what it was and did not hurry toward it.

He slid one finger inside her and Diane's forehead came down harder against his temple and her hips came forward to meet it. She said, "Yes," quiet and fierce, and then again, "yes," and her thighs closed around his hand.

That was the thing he'd remember, later — the way she did it. Not a flinch, not a retreat. She clamped down on him, both thighs pressing his wrist between them, hard enough that the bones of his hand felt it, and she held him there, and her hips worked in small tight circles against his palm and her breath was hot and ragged in his ear and she was saying things now, low, half of them not words.

"That's it," she said. "Don't stop, don't you dare stop, I'll —"

"You'll what."

"I'll come on your hand in your friend's kitchen with the wine still corked, that's what I'll do." Her voice had gone to gravel and it was shaking. "And then I'll write about it better than you could ever — ah —"

His thumb found her again and pressed and her sentence went to pieces.

"Diane," Carol said.

It was the first thing she'd said in a while and it was quiet, and it went through the kitchen like a struck match. Diane's eyes came open and her head lifted off Oliver's temple and she looked across the table at Carol, and Oliver watched her face do something he'd never seen it do — she looked caught, and she looked furious about being caught, and underneath both of those she looked like she wanted to be seen.

"What," Diane said, and it came out breathless and sharp at once.

"Look at me while he does it," Carol said. "Not at the wall. Not at the paper. At me." She had her chin on her fist still, and her blue eyes were steady and her freckles had gone dark against her cheeks. "You said you wanted to be heard. So be heard."

Diane's throat moved. Her hips had not stopped — they were still working, small and slow, against Oliver's hand. He could feel the rhythm of it in his wrist and in his own pulse. He kept his fingers where they were and let her ride them and did not push her toward anything.

"You're a terrible girl," Diane said to Carol, and it came out almost fond. "You know that? You sit there with your bare foot on the rung and you watch and you —" Her breath hitched. "You watch like it's a story you're going to write down."

"I'm going to write it down," Carol said. "Every word. And you're going to read it tomorrow and hate me."

"I'm going to read it tomorrow and —" Diane's thighs tightened around his hand and her voice climbed and broke. "And I'm going to — Oliver, now, don't you — I'm going to —"

She came with her eyes open and fixed on Carol across the scarred table.

Oliver felt it happen in his hand — the clench, the flutter, the wet rush of it over his fingers, and her thigh hard as a bowstring against his wrist and her nails in his shoulder through the shirt. She made almost no sound. A caught breath, a long shuddering exhale, and then her forehead came down against the side of his head and stayed there and her whole weight leaned into him, and her hand slid down off his shoulder and hung.

The lamp hummed. The fridge kicked on with a soft clunk.

Diane's hips gave one last slow roll against his palm and then went still. She stayed like that — bent over him, her hair over his ear, her breath slowing — for the length of three or four heartbeats, and Oliver sat with his fingers still inside her and did not move them, because moving them now would be a kind of speaking. He didn't have the words yet.

Then she straightened.

It was abrupt. That was the thing he'd remember too — how fast it was. She came up off his shoulder and her hand found the table's edge and she pushed herself upright, and his fingers slid out of her and she felt it, he saw her feel it, a flicker across her face — and then she stepped back, one heel and then the other, and her thighs came apart and her skirt dropped back down into its soft gray fold like a curtain coming down after a play.

"Right," she said.

Her voice was not the gravel voice. It was the meeting voice, the panel voice, and it had a crack running through the middle of it that she was doing her level best to paper over. She smoothed her skirt down with both palms. She tucked her hair back behind one ear and then the other, and the second one didn't take and she let it fall.

"Write," she said. "Not touch. Write."

Oliver's hand was still in the air where she'd been, wet to the knuckles, and he looked at it and then at her.

"That's the order?" he said. "From the woman who just came on my hand?"

"That's the order." Diane picked up her wine glass, and it was empty, and she looked into it anyway. "You've had your — you've had your demonstration. Now you write the woman who does the wanting instead of the woman who gets wanted. That's the whole point of the exercise, and I'm not going to sit here and let you turn it into a —" She set the glass down. Her red nails were not quite steady on the stem. "A thing."

Carol laughed. It was a small laugh, not unkind, and it came out of her nose. "You're running," she said.

"I'm redirecting."

"You're running, and you're doing it in a very good blouse."

Diane turned and looked at her, and for a moment the two of them were just women in a kitchen, one standing with her skirt smoothed and her hair half-tucked, one sitting with her chin on her fist and her bare foot on the rung, and Oliver sat between them with his hand still wet and his page in front of him and understood, with a clarity that had nothing to do with the story, that he had just been handed the thing he'd been trying to write all night and it was sitting in the room with him and it had two faces.

He picked up the pen.

Diane's eyes came back to him. She watched the nib come down on the page, and something in her shoulders let go by a degree, and she said, quieter now, "Good. That's — good. Write her. And write her right."

The nib scratched. Oliver wrote one line, then another, and the ink went down dark and sure, and he did not look at Diane standing over him with her skirt smoothed and her hand on the back of the chair, and he did not look at Carol across the table, and the pen moved.

He wrote: She stood up too fast when it was over, because staying bent over him was a way of saying something she hadn't decided to say.

He read the line back to himself and it was true, it was the truest sentence he'd written all night, and it was a sentence about a woman standing up too fast — which meant the next thing on the page was not a sentence at all. It was the woman herself, still standing there with her hand on the back of his chair and her skirt smoothed and her hair half-tucked and her green eyes doing that flat bright thing, waiting for him to be done with her.

Oliver set the pen down.

"No," he said. "That's not how it goes."

Diane's eyebrow started to climb. "Excuse me?"

"The woman in the story." He turned on the chair and got his feet under him and stood, and the chair scraped back and he didn't care about the sound now. "She doesn't stand up and smooth her skirt and tell him to write. That's you. That's the woman who's been running since she walked in the door. The woman in the story stays bent over the table, because she hasn't decided what to say yet and her body's already decided for her."

"Oliver—"

He got a hand on her hip. Just the one, flat over the gray wool, and he felt her go still under it the way a struck bell goes still — not quiet, holding the note.

"You wanted to be written," he said. "So get on the table."

Diane's mouth opened. Nothing came out of it. That was a first, and Carol made a small sound at the other end of the table, something between a gasp and a laugh, and Oliver heard her chair creak as she sat up straight.

"You've lost your mind," Diane said. Her voice had the panel voice on it again, and the panel voice had a crack in it. "You think because I let you put your hand under my skirt in a kitchen that you can just—"

"I think you came on my fingers and then told me to write instead of touch, and I think that was the biggest lie anybody's told in this room tonight." He kept his hand where it was. Not pulling. Not pushing. "So I'm asking. Get on the table. Bent over. Face down. And I'll write the woman who stays."

The kitchen hummed. Diane's throat moved. Her hand came off the back of the chair and hung at her side, and her fingers curled and uncurled once. She looked at the scarred wood of the table like it was a manuscript she'd been handed and told to sign.

"The neighbors," she said.

"It's a Tuesday and the windows are shut."

"My skirt—"

"Is going to be around your waist. I know."

She laughed. It came out of her wrong, too high, and she cut it off with her teeth. Then she put both hands flat on the table and hoisted herself up onto it, and the short leg knocked and the whole thing shifted a half inch and the wine bottle rang against the counter behind her, and Diane lay down on her stomach on Carol's scarred kitchen table with her cheek against the wood and her auburn hair spilling out across it, and her heels came up off the floor and hung.

"There," she said into the wood. "Happy?"

"Not yet."

Oliver got her skirt up. Both hands, the wool gathering in folds, up over the backs of her knees and the long pale stretch of her thighs and then over the curve of her ass. He bunched it at the small of her back and left it there. She was wearing underwear after all — a dark gray pair, plain, nothing like what he'd have written her in — and they were wet through the middle in a stripe that showed darker than the rest. He looked at that stripe for a moment and then hooked his thumb in the waistband and pulled them down.

Diane lifted her hips to help him. She didn't say anything about it. He got them down over her knees and off one ankle and they hung from the other and she didn't kick them free.

Carol had come around the table. She stood at the end of it with her back against the counter and her arms folded and her bare foot up on the cabinet's toe-kick, and she was watching with her lips slightly parted and her eyes going from Diane's face to Oliver's hands and back.

"You're going to want to move the salt shaker," Carol said.

Oliver moved the salt shaker. He moved Mina's page too, out from under Diane's elbow, and set it on the counter by the stove where it would be safe, and then he stood behind her with one hand on her hip and the other on the small of her back and looked down at her — the long pale back, the gray skirt bunched, the dark hair spread across the wood, the red nails of one hand curled loose against the table's edge.

"Tell me," he said.

"Tell you what."

"You know what."

Her shoulders moved with her breathing. "I want you to fuck me," she said, into the wood, flat and fast. "There. Is that plain enough. I want you to put your cock in me and I want it to be —" She stopped.

"Hard."

"Yes." It came out muffled. "Hard. Don't be nice about it. I've had nice. Nice is what you get when nobody's paying attention."

Oliver got his shorts down over his hips and took himself in his hand. He was hard already, had been hard since she'd stood up off the tile with her hair wrecked, and the cool air of the kitchen crossed him and made him ache. He stepped in close and set the head of his cock against her. She was so wet that it slid along her without any finding to do at all, a slick hot glide from her clit back to her opening and forward again, and Diane's whole body flinched and then pushed back into it.

"Oh, God," she said. "Oh, that's — don't tease me, you little—"

He pushed into her.

Not slow. She'd asked, and he'd heard her ask, and the sound she made when he went into her was not a sound she'd have allowed herself in any other room — a long low broken thing, her cheek grinding against the wood, her fingers scrabbling at the table's edge and finding nothing to hold. She was tight and she was wet. She took him all the way to the base in one push, and Oliver's hand went flat on her lower back and held her there while the shock of it went through both of them.

"Fuck," he said. It came out of him without permission. "God. Diane."

"Don't stop." Her voice was wrecked already. "Don't you dare stop, don't be polite, I will end you—"

He pulled back and drove in again. The table knocked against the wall. Diane made a sound like she'd been hit and pushed her hips back to meet him and the slap of it went through the kitchen, skin on skin, loud and wet and specific.

Carol said, "Jesus," very quietly, from the counter.

Oliver found a rhythm. It wasn't a gentle one. He got both hands on her hips and pulled her back into him as he drove forward, and the table rocked and the short leg ticked against the tile and Diane's hair slid across the wood with every push. She had her forehead down and her hands out flat and she was talking into the table, a stream of it, half of it not words.

"That's it — that's — harder, God, harder, is that all you've — oh —"

He gave her harder. His hips snapped and her whole body jolted up the table and she caught herself on her elbows and laughed, wild and breathless, and then the laugh broke in the middle and turned into something else.

"Say it," he said.

"Say what?"

"What you told me to write. Say it out loud."

"I—" Her breath caught on the rhythm. "I'm good at it." It came out small and fierce at once, muffled by the wood, and then louder, defiant, her cheek turning so the words came out clear: "I'm good at it. Tell me I'm good at it."

"You're good at it." He said it flat and sure, no sweetness in it, and drove in on the last word. "You're so fucking good at it, look at you, bent over a table in your own skirt—"

"Yes—"

"—with your hair in your face and your ass up and you can't even—"

"Don't stop talking." Her voice cracked. "Don't you dare stop talking, you nice boy, you—"

"You wanted to be heard." He got a hand in her hair. Not pulling hard, just gathering it up off the wood, the auburn of it warm and soft in his fist, and he held her head up a little and her back arched and she made a sound like a woman going under water. "So be heard. Let Carol hear you."

Carol's voice came from the counter, low and steady. "I hear her."

Diane's hips stuttered. Oliver felt it — the clench of her, sudden and involuntary, the whole long channel of her tightening around him. She said, "You—" and couldn't finish it, and Carol said it again, slower, like she was writing it down as she said it.

"I hear you, Diane. You're good at it. You're so good at it you've got your cheek on my table and your come on his hand and you're still telling him what to do."

Diane came. Or she started to — her thighs went rigid and her back bowed. She pushed her hips back onto him so hard the table jumped, and Oliver held his rhythm through it, driving into her while she shook. She was saying his name now, Oliver, Oliver, and something that might have been a curse and might have been a prayer, and her hand came off the table and reached back and found his thigh and her nails dug in through the fabric of his shorts.

He kept going. That was the thing he'd remember — that he didn't stop when she came, that he rode her through it while her body clenched and fluttered and went on clenching. She was gasping now, oversensitive, half laughing, saying, "Wait, wait, I can't — oh, don't you dare—"

"You said don't be nice."

"I said—" She broke off into a moan that was almost a sob. "God, I hate you, I hate you, don't stop."

The rhythm changed. He could feel it building at the base of his spine, that tightening, and his hand in her hair tightened with it and his other hand came down hard on her hip and he pulled her back to meet him and the table was knocking the wall in a steady rhythm now and the wine bottle rang against the counter with every push and he didn't care, none of them cared.

"Diane—"

"In me." Her voice was raw. "Don't you pull out, don't you dare pull out, I want to feel it—"

"Say it again."

"Come in me." She turned her face against the wood and her eyes found Carol across the room and held her. "Come in me, Oliver, fill me up, I want to walk home with it running down my leg—"

He came with a groan that came up out of his chest and he drove in deep and held there, his hips pressed flush to her. He felt it go out of him in long pulses, felt her cunt take it and clench around him, felt her whole body shudder and go still under his hands. The kitchen tilted. The lamp hummed. He was aware of the sweat on his back and the cold air on his ass and the soft warm weight of her hair in his fist. He let go of it and it fell back down across the wood.

For a moment nobody moved. Oliver stood with his hands on her hips and his cock still in her and his breath coming hard, and Diane lay flat on the table with her cheek against the scar and her hair everywhere and one shoe still on and one off, and Carol stood at the counter with her arms folded and her foot on the toe-kick and her freckles dark against her cheeks.

Then Diane's hips gave a last slow roll, a small deliberate thing, and she made a sound that was almost a purr and almost a groan.

"Well," she said, into the wood. Her voice was scraped raw. "Write that down."

Comments

Be the first to share your thoughts on this chapter.