Poolside Claim
The New Normal · Chapter 5 of 5

Poolside Claim

I settle back onto the lounger, the sun hot on my skin, and Dana swims over to the edge directly in front of me, water beading on her shoulders. She pulls herself up, dripping, and stands over me, her black triangle top clinging to her tits. 'Mr. Hayes,' she says, loud enough for the others to hear, 'I think I need more sunscreen on my ass.' She turns, presenting her wet cheeks to me, and I see Evelyn's smile from the corner of my eye—approval, not jealousy. I reach for the bottle, my hand already slick with coconut oil, and I hear Chloe's soft laugh from the water as I press my palm to Dana's skin.

The worn teak boards pressed warm against my back as I settled deeper into the lounger, the sun a heavy hand on my chest. The air was thick—chlorine and coconut oil and the particular humidity of a summer afternoon that had stopped trying to be anything but hot. I let my eyes drift half-closed, listening to the sounds of the pool: water lapping against tile, the distant hum of the filter, Chloe's laugh cutting through the heat like something sharp and bright.

Evelyn was beside me, stretched out on her own lounger with a magazine she wasn't reading. I could feel her presence without looking—the way she'd angled her chair toward mine, the soft rustle of pages turning every few minutes, the weight of her attention settling on me like a second layer of sun.

"You're staring," I said, not opening my eyes.

"I'm admiring." Her voice was lazy, amused. "There's a difference."

"Is there?"

"Staring is passive. Admiring is intentional." I heard her shift, the fabric of her chair creaking. "I'm being very intentional right now."

I opened my eyes and turned my head. She was propped on one elbow, her blonde hair falling over her shoulder, red lipstick still perfect despite the heat. Her blue eyes held mine with that new knowingness—the one that had appeared sometime in the last few days and hadn't left.

"Intentional about what, exactly?"

Her smile curved. "About watching my husband enjoy his Saturday."

Before I could answer, the water broke. A splash, a ripple, and then Dana was cutting through the pool in a clean crawl, her strokes efficient, her body a dark shape moving under the surface. She surfaced at the edge directly in front of me, shaking her head to clear the water from her eyes, and I watched the droplets arc through the air and catch the light.

She pulled herself up.

The motion was unhurried, deliberate. Her arms flexed as she pressed her palms flat on the deck, water streaming down her shoulders, her collarbone, the hollow of her throat. Her black triangle top clung to her tits like a second skin, the fabric darkened to near-translucence where it was wet. She rose up out of the pool in one smooth movement, water cascading off her thighs, her hips, the flat plane of her stomach, and then she was standing over me, dripping onto the warm teak.

Drops landed on my chest. Cool against my hot skin.

"Mr. Hayes." Her voice carried—pitched loud enough to reach the water, to reach Chloe, to reach Evelyn. "I think I need more sunscreen on my ass."

She turned before I could respond.

Presented herself.

Her back was to me now, her wet cheeks rising from the water-darkened fabric of her bottoms—a thin strip of black that had ridden up, showing more of her than it covered. Water beaded on the curve of her ass, catching the sun, and she held the pose a beat longer than necessary, her head turned just enough that I could see the edge of her smile.

From the corner of my eye, I caught Evelyn's expression.

Approval. Not jealousy. Her lips were curved, her eyes bright, and she made no move to interrupt, no sound of protest. She simply watched, the magazine forgotten in her lap, as if this was exactly what she'd expected to happen.

As if she'd already decided to let it.

From the water, Chloe laughed—a soft, knowing sound that carried across the deck. I didn't look at her. I didn't need to. I could hear the grin in it.

The sunscreen bottle sat on the small table between the loungers. Coconut oil, the cheap kind that smelled like vacation. I reached for it, my fingers closing around the warm plastic, and I heard the click of the cap as I opened it.

Dana didn't move.

She stood there, dripping, her ass presented to me like an offering, and the whole deck had gone quiet—the filter humming, the water lapping, three women waiting to see what I would do.

I poured oil into my palm.

It was warm from sitting in the sun, slick and golden, and I spread it across my hand with a slow, deliberate motion. The sound of it—skin on skin, the soft slide of oil—seemed louder than it should have been.

"Dana," I said.

She looked back over her shoulder, water still beading on her skin, her green eyes bright with something that wasn't quite a dare.

"Yes, Mr. Hayes?"

I didn't answer with words. I pressed my palm to her skin.

The contact was electric—her wet, sun-warmed cheek under my oiled hand, the give of her flesh, the way she exhaled softly as I made contact. My fingers spread wide, covering as much of her as I could, and I felt her shiver—a small, involuntary tremor that ran through her body and disappeared.

She was warm. So warm. The sun had been on her all afternoon, and the heat of her skin under my palm was different from the heat of the air—deeper, more alive. I moved my hand in a slow circle, spreading the oil, feeling the smooth curve of her ass give under my fingers.

"That's better," she said, her voice pitched low now, meant only for me. "I was starting to burn."

"Can't have that."

I worked the oil into her skin, my hand moving in slow, deliberate strokes. Her bottoms were still wet, the fabric clinging, and I let my fingers ride the edge of them—not pulling, not pushing, just tracing the line where fabric met flesh.

She made a small sound. Not quite a sigh. Not quite a moan. Something in between.

From the water, Chloe's voice floated over: "Dana, you're going to monopolize him all day?"

Dana laughed, but she didn't move away from my hand. "He's doing me a favor. You want some?"

"Maybe later."

I kept my hand moving, my palm gliding over her skin, and I felt the tension in her body shift—the way she leaned into my touch, the way her hips tilted slightly, the way her breath came a little faster. She was enjoying this. More than enjoying it. She was performing it, and she knew I knew.

Evelyn's voice came from beside me, soft and amused: "You're going to give her a sunburn if you miss a spot."

I glanced at her. She was watching my hand on Dana's ass with open interest, her magazine now folded in her lap, her blue eyes tracking my movements.

"I'm being thorough," I said.

"I can see that." Her smile deepened. "I like thorough."

Dana shifted her weight, spreading her stance slightly, and I felt the movement through my palm—the subtle invitation in it. She was giving me more access, offering more of herself, and the deck seemed to hold its breath around us.

I slid my hand lower, following the curve of her ass, and my fingers brushed the edge of her bottoms. The fabric was thin, wet, and I could feel the heat of her through it—the warmth of her skin, the hint of something softer beneath.

She inhaled sharply.

"Mr. Hayes," she said, her voice a little breathless, "you're getting a bit—"

"Thorough?"

"I was going to say personal."

I let my hand rest there, my fingers just at the edge of her bottoms, not moving. The sun beat down on us. The water lapped. Somewhere behind me, Chloe had gone quiet, and I could feel her watching—could feel the weight of her gaze on my hand, on Dana's body, on the space between us.

"Is that a problem?" I asked.

Dana was quiet for a moment. Then she shook her head, the movement small, almost imperceptible.

"No," she said. "No problem at all."

Evelyn laughed softly, and the sound broke the tension—not destroying it, but reshaping it. Dana relaxed under my hand, leaning into my touch again, and I resumed the slow, circular motion, working the oil into her skin with the same deliberate care as before.

But something had changed.

The air was different now—charged, expectant. The deck had silently agreed to something, and I could feel it in the way Dana stood, in the way Evelyn watched, in the way Chloe's laughter had gone quiet and watchful.

My hand was on her ass, and everyone knew it.

And the next move was mine to make.

I kept my palm pressed to her skin, the oil warm between us, and I let the moment stretch—let it breathe, let it settle into something that felt like a promise. Dana's body was still under my hand, waiting, and I could feel her pulse through the heat of her skin, a steady beat that matched my own.

"There," I said, my voice low. "That should do it."

I didn't move my hand.

Dana didn't move either.

For a long moment, we stayed like that—her ass under my palm, the sun hot on both of us, the sound of the pool filling the silence. Then she turned her head, looking back at me over her shoulder, and her green eyes held mine with something that was equal parts challenge and invitation.

"Thanks, Mr. Hayes," she said, her voice pitched just for me. "I feel much better now."

She stepped away, finally, and my hand fell to my side, the oil already cooling on my skin. She walked to the edge of the pool and dove in, a clean, smooth entry that barely made a splash, and I watched her surface on the far side, shaking the water from her purple hair.

Chloe swam over to her, and I heard their voices—low, conspiratorial, punctuated by laughter. I didn't catch the words, but I caught the glances they threw my way, quick and knowing.

Evelyn's hand found my arm. Her fingers were cool against my heated skin.

"You're good at that," she said.

"At sunscreen?"

"At making them want more."

I looked at her. Her blue eyes were warm, her smile soft, and there was no jealousy in them—only a kind of pleased satisfaction, like a woman watching a plan come together.

"Is that what I'm doing?" I asked.

"You know it is." She squeezed my arm, then let go, reaching for her magazine. "And I, for one, am enjoying the show."

I settled back into the lounger, the sun still hot on my skin, the smell of coconut oil and chlorine thick in the air. In the pool, Dana and Chloe were laughing about something, their heads bent together, and I could feel the weight of the moment still hanging over the deck—the promise of it, the possibility.

My hand still smelled like coconut oil.

I closed my eyes, and I let the sun take me.

The sun had me in that place where thinking becomes optional. The buzz of the afternoon—chlorine, coconut oil, the weight of three women's attention—had settled into my bones like a second drink I hadn't paid for yet. Evelyn's magazine rustled beside me. The water lapped. Chloe and Dana's voices had dropped to that conspiratorial murmur that meant they thought they were being subtle.

I wasn't thinking about anything in particular. That was the point.

Then my throat registered how dry it was. The kind of dry that comes from an afternoon in the sun and a morning that had already cost me more than most men spend in a week.

"I need a beer," I said, pushing myself up from the lounger.

Evelyn didn't look up from her magazine. "There's a cold six-pack in the garage fridge."

"That's where I was headed."

"Mm." She turned a page. "Don't hurry back."

I didn't ask what she meant by that. We were past the point of needing to.

The sliding door sighed open and I stepped into the air conditioning, the change hitting me like a wall. The house was dim and quiet, the kitchen counters still holding the evidence of breakfast—a coffee mug, a plate with toast crumbs, the particular mess of a morning that had started one way and ended somewhere else entirely.

I walked through to the garage, grabbed a bottle from the six-pack, and twisted the cap off over the sink. The first sip went down cold and bitter and perfect. I leaned against the counter, letting the A/C dry the sweat on my skin, and I didn't think about anything at all.

The sliding door opened again.

I heard it—the soft hiss of the track, the click of it closing. Footsteps on tile. Light ones, deliberate. I didn't turn around. I took another sip of beer and waited.

"Mr. Hayes."

Dana's voice. Not calling from the door—close. Too close. She'd crossed the kitchen without me hearing her stop.

I turned. She was standing a few feet away, still in her damp bikini, her purple hair dark where it was wet, water beading on her collarbone. She'd wrapped a towel around her waist, tied loose at her hip, and the triangle top was still damp enough to cling.

"Thirsty?" I asked.

"Something like that." She tilted her head, green eyes bright. "You left kind of suddenly."

"I left to get a beer."

"Mm-hmm." She took a step closer. "And now you're standing in your kitchen, drinking it, all by yourself."

"That's generally how drinking works."

"Unless someone joins you."

She reached past me—deliberately, her body brushing mine as she opened the fridge and pulled out a bottle of water. She didn't step back. She stood there, hip against the counter, looking up at me, and the space between us was doing something that had nothing to do with the temperature of the room.

"You know," she said, twisting the cap off her water, "you never did finish the sunscreen."

"I finished the sunscreen."

"You did my ass." She took a sip, watching me over the bottle. "I had other spots."

I looked at her. She was nineteen, standing in my kitchen in a wet bikini, telling me she had spots I hadn't covered. Her towel had slipped a little, showing the curve of her hip where the bikini bottom cut high.

And I realized I was done pretending.

The girls had already tasted my cock—Dana had swallowed my cum while Amber screamed my name. The line was so far behind us I couldn't see it anymore. And here she was, in my kitchen, making it obvious she wanted what Amber had gotten.

"Dana," I said, taking another sip of beer.

"Yes, Mr. Hayes?"

"You're not being subtle."

"I'm not trying to be." She set her water down on the counter. "I've been trying to be subtle for two years. I'm done with it."

"Done with it how?"

"Done with pretending I don't think about you." She took a step closer. "Done with pretending I didn't watch Amber take your cock and think about how much I wanted it in my mouth."

There it was. Laid out flat between us, the way she'd always done things.

"You're pretty direct," I said.

"You seem like a guy who appreciates direct."

I finished my beer, set the bottle down, and didn't move. She was close enough now that I could smell her—chlorine and coconut oil and something underneath that was just her, warm and young.

"I do," I said. "But I also appreciate not being rushed."

"Who's rushing?" She reached up and touched my chest—just her fingertips on my bare skin, light enough that I could have imagined it. "I'm just standing here, talking to you in your kitchen. That's all."

"That's all."

"Mm." Her fingers traced a slow line down my sternum. "Unless you want it to be more."

I caught her wrist—gently, not hard. She didn't pull away. Her pulse was going fast under my thumb.

"You've got a lot of nerve," I said.

"I've had a lot of practice." She didn't look away. "Two years of practice, thinking about this."

"Thinking about what?"

"About you." Her voice dropped. "About what it would feel like to have you inside me. About whether you'd be rough or gentle." She stepped closer, her body pressing against my hand. "About whether you'd treat me like a woman or like a girl."

My thumb moved on her wrist. She shivered.

"And what did you decide?" I asked.

"That I'd let you decide."

She said it like it was nothing—like she hadn't just handed me everything she had. But I could feel her pulse racing under my fingers, and I could see the way her breath had gone shallow, the way her chest was rising faster.

I let go of her wrist.

"I'm going to finish my beer," I said. "Then I'm going to decide."

She smiled—slow, knowing, the smile of a girl who'd already gotten what she wanted. "Take your time."

I picked up the bottle, took a sip, and watched her. She didn't move. She just stood there in my kitchen, wet and waiting, and I let the moment stretch until it felt like something solid.

"You know what I noticed?" I said.

"What?"

"You watched Amber take my cock, and you swallowed what I gave her." I let that sit. "That's not the move of a girl who wants to be on the sidelines."

"No," she said softly. "It's not."

"So what do you want, Dana? Tell me straight."

She looked at me for a long moment. Then she reached down, hooked her fingers in the towel at her hip, and let it drop to the floor.

"I want you to fuck my ass," she said. "I want to feel your cock stretching me open. I want to know what Amber felt when she screamed your name." She stepped out of the puddle of towel, closer to me. "And I'm not going to pretend I don't."

The kitchen was quiet. The A/C hummed. Somewhere in the house, a clock ticked.

I set the beer down.

"Turn around," I said.

She did. Slowly. Her back to me, her hands braced on the counter, her ass presented to me in the same way it had been at the pool—but closer now, private, nothing between us but the thin fabric of her bikini bottoms.

"You've been thinking about this for two years," I said, stepping up behind her.

"Yes."

"And you want me to decide how it goes."

"Yes."

I reached down and hooked my fingers in the waistband of her bottoms. She was wet—I could see it through the fabric, the way it clung to her. I pulled them down, slowly, letting the fabric peel away from her skin, and she didn't help me and she didn't stop me.

She just stood there, naked from the waist down, her ass bare and waiting.

"Look at you," I said. "Nineteen years old, bent over my kitchen counter, asking me to fuck her."

"Asking you to fuck me," she repeated. "Yes."

I ran my hand over her ass, feeling the warmth of her skin. She was softer than Amber—rounder, more cushion. I squeezed, and she made a small sound, pressing back into my hand.

"You want me to be rough?" I asked.

The pause stretched. "I want you to decide," she said again. "Whatever you want. That's what I want."

That was all I needed to hear.

I undid my shorts and let them drop. My cock was already hard—had been hard since she dropped the towel—and I wrapped my hand around it, stroking once, twice, feeling the heat of her close.

She was watching me over her shoulder, her green eyes dark, her lips parted.

"Please," she whispered.

I stepped closer, pressed the head of my cock against her. She was tight—I could feel it even at the entrance—and I pushed, just enough to stretch her, and she gasped.

"That's it," I said. "Take it."

She pushed back, taking me deeper, and I felt her clench around me. She was tight and hot and slick, and she was moaning already, her hands gripping the counter edge.

"Fuck," she breathed. "Fuck, that's—you feel so big—"

"You wanted this," I said, pushing deeper. "Two years, you've been thinking about this."

"I know—oh God—I know—"

I bottomed out inside her, my hips flush against her ass, and I held there. She was trembling, her whole body shaking, and I could feel her pulse around my cock, the flutter of her muscles trying to adjust to the stretch.

"Look at you," I said. "Taking all of it."

"Yes," she moaned. "Yes, please—move—"

I pulled back, slow, almost all the way out, and then I pushed back in, hard. She cried out, her knuckles going white on the counter, and I did it again—slow out, hard in—until I found a rhythm that made her voice break.

She was so wet. I could hear it—the slick sound of my cock sliding into her, the way her body opened for me. She was soaked, her thighs glistening, and I reached around and found her clit with my fingers, pressing as I thrust.

"Oh—oh God—" She was losing words, her head dropping forward, her hips pushing back to meet me. "Mr. Hayes—please—"

"Please what?"

"Don't stop—"

I didn't. I kept thrusting, deep and hard, my fingers working her clit, and she was coming apart under me—her body tightening, her voice rising, her hands clawing at the counter.

"I'm—I'm going to—"

"Come for me, Dana."

She did. Her body convulsed around my cock, clenching so hard I could feel every pulse of it, and she screamed—not my name, just a sound, raw and broken, her whole body shaking as she came.

I didn't stop. I kept thrusting through it, feeling her tighten and release around me, and I was close—so close—the heat of her pulling me toward the edge.

"I'm going to fill you," I said, my voice rough. "I'm going to come in your ass."

"Yes," she gasped. "Yes, please—fill me—"

I came with a groan, my hips slamming into her, my cock pulsing deep inside her as I emptied into her. She moaned with every pulse, her body still trembling, and I held there until I was spent, my forehead pressed to her shoulder blade.

For a long moment, neither of us moved.

Then I pulled out, slowly, and watched my cum leak out of her, running down her thigh. She straightened, wincing slightly, and turned to face me. Her cheeks were flushed, her lips parted, her eyes bright.

"Well," she said, her voice hoarse. "That was worth the wait."

I reached for my beer, took a long sip, and grinned at her.

"You're going to be trouble," I said.

"I've been telling you that for two years."

She bent down, pulled her bikini bottoms back up, and walked to the sliding door. At the threshold, she looked back over her shoulder, a smile playing on her lips.

"Thanks for the sunscreen, Mr. Hayes."

She slid the door open and stepped back into the sun.

Comments

Be the first to share your thoughts on this chapter.

The End

Thanks for reading