The Table Talk
Survivor's Due · Chapter 11 of 19

The Table Talk

Back at the shelter, the fire crackles as Adam, Clara, and Emily share the last of the smoked fish, the silence comfortable but charged. Emily sets down her portion and looks from Adam to Clara, her voice steady as she says, 'I've been thinking about what we call this — and what we want from it.' Clara's hand stills on her knee, and Adam watches Emily's face as she lays out her wants: to keep going, to not stop, to let the island decide what comes next. Clara laughs softly, then admits she wants the same — and more, that she wants to see Emily grow round with Adam's child, to be there for it. The fire pops, and Adam reaches out, taking both their hands, and says, 'Then that's what we do — no labels, no rules, just us.'

The fish had gone cold an hour ago and nobody had said so. Adam turned his piece over on the flat stone, thumb pressed to the charred seam where the skin had split, and the flesh gave a little under the pressure, oil beading out dark and slow. He put it in his mouth. Smoke and salt and something faintly sweet underneath, the way the meat got when it had hung over the fire long enough to forget it had ever been swimming.

Across the coals, Clara pulled her knees up and worked a knot out of her calf with her thumb. The firelight moved across the tarp they'd strung last week, and the shadow of her hand ran up the fabric and shrank again, over and over, like something breathing. Beyond the treeline the sea was doing what it always did at night, a low hush that never quite stopped, that you only noticed when the talking did.

Emily sat cross-legged on the sand with her back against the post, close enough that Adam could feel the warmth of her through the gap between them. She had her portion in her lap, half of it left. She'd been eating slower than usual. He'd noticed that at the start of the meal and hadn't said anything about it, the way he hadn't said anything about the way she was looking at the fire.

"There's one left on the rack," Adam said. "We can split it tomorrow, or smoke it with the next catch. Depends on the tide."

"Depends on the tide," Clara said, and smiled without opening her eyes. "You sound like a man who's been doing this his whole life."

"Feels like it." He wiped his fingers on his thigh. "Nine days and it feels like the boat was somebody else's life."

Emily set her fish down on the stone. Not the way you set something down to pick it up again — flat, deliberate, her fingertips staying on it a second after she let go. Adam watched her do it and felt the shift in the air before she spoke, the way you feel a fish take the line before the line moves.

"I've been thinking," Emily said.

Clara's eyes opened.

"About what we call this." Emily's voice didn't shake. That was the thing that got Adam's attention — how steady it was. She looked at him first, then at Clara, and her chin came up the way it did when she'd decided something and was past caring whether it was a good idea. "And what we want from it. Not tonight, not tomorrow. From all of it."

Clara's hand went still on her knee. She'd been rubbing the knot, and now her thumb just rested there, the firelight picking out the pale half-moon of her nail.

Adam didn't reach for the fish. His hand stayed where it was, and his eyes stayed on Emily's face, and he made himself wait.

"I don't want to be the one who says it and then it's ruined," Emily said. "So I'm just going to say it, and if it's wrong, it's wrong, and we'll know." She took a breath. "I want to keep going. I don't want to stop because it's strange, or because some people back home would say — I don't care what they'd say. They aren't here. They didn't wash up with us. I want to not stop. I want to stop pretending there's a version of this that ends when the fish run out or when somebody's conscience gets the better of them."

The fire popped. A spark jumped the ring and died in the sand, and nobody looked at it.

"I want to let the island decide," Emily said. "Whatever that means. However long it means. I'm not asking for a word for it. I'm asking that we stop being careful about it."

Then she was quiet, and the quiet had weight to it, the way the air does before a storm comes in off the water. Clara's hand hadn't moved. The sea went on hushing itself beyond the trees, and Adam could hear his own breathing, and the fire, and nothing else.

He had known, in the way he knew things on the island now — in his gut, before his head caught up — that a thing like this was coming. Emily had been chewing on it all day. He'd seen it in the way she'd watched him on the ridge, in the way she'd said we should get back and then hadn't moved. He had not known it would come out like this, plain and unapologetic, laid down on the stone between them like a piece of the catch.

"Say something," Emily said. Not pleading. Just asking.

Adam looked at Clara. Clara was looking at Emily, and her face was doing something he couldn't read — not shock, not anger. Her jaw was loose. Her eyes had a shine to them that could have been the fire.

"Well," Clara said, and her voice came out lower than usual, roughened. "I raised a girl who says what she means. That's something."

"Mom."

"I'm not making a joke." Clara let her knees down slowly, her bare feet settling in the sand, and she turned her head to Adam. "She's asking you, and she's asking me, and I've been sitting here thinking the same thing for a week and not saying it because I thought I was the only one old enough to be ashamed."

Adam set his fish down. "You're not ashamed."

"No." Clara's mouth curved, wry, and she looked at the fire. "I'm something. I don't think it's shame."

Emily pulled her knees up and wrapped her arms around them, but she didn't look away from Clara. "So what do you want?"

Clara was quiet a moment. The fire settled, the logs shifting and hissing, and she reached over and picked up a bit of the fish from the stone and ate it, slowly, as though she were giving herself time.

"I want the same," she said at last. "I want us to stop pretending. I want the island to decide." She dusted salt from her fingers. "And more than that. I want to watch this one grow round." She nodded at Emily, and her voice didn't falter. "I want to see you full with him, Emily. I want to be here for it. I want to feel the baby kick under your skin and know that the three of us made it possible, on this rock, with our own hands."

The fire popped again, and Adam felt the words land in his chest like a stone dropped in still water.

Emily's eyes had gone wide. Not shocked — something else. Her hand had drifted to her own belly without her seeming to know it, palm flat below her navel, and she was staring at Clara as if seeing her for the first time.

"You mean that," Emily said.

"I don't say things I don't mean." Clara's voice was soft. "You know that about me by now."

Adam watched Emily's face — the flush climbing her throat, the way her mouth had come open a little, the way her hand stayed pressed flat to her stomach. He felt something turn over in his own chest, heavy and hot, and he couldn't tell whether it was hunger or fear or something with no name at all.

"Adam." Clara had turned to him. Her hazel eyes were steady on his, and there was no apology in them. "You've been quiet. That's not like you."

He looked at the two of them — his mother, his sister, the firelight moving over their faces, the shelter wall behind them, the dark pressing in past the mouth of the lean-to — and he felt the whole weight of the island settle on his shoulders the way it did when he stood at the water's edge and looked out at a sea with nothing on it.

"I've been thinking the same thing," he said. "Since the ridge."

Emily's breath caught. He heard it.

"I didn't say it because I didn't know how to say it without it sounding like I was deciding for all of us." He rubbed the back of his neck, the salt grit under his palm. "That's what I do. I decide things and then they're decided. My father did it and I do it and it's not always right." He looked at Clara. "You said I sound like him."

"I did."

"Then let me not sound like him for once." He reached out — across the flat stone, over the last of the fish — and took Clara's hand in his, and then Emily's, and held them both, one in each of his, and felt how warm they were, how real, the calluses on Clara's palm from hauling driftwood and the small softness of Emily's fingers closing around his.

"Then that's what we do," he said. "No labels. No rules. Just us. Whatever the island gives us, we take it. Whatever it takes from us, we pay it." He looked at Emily. "And if it's a child — then it's a child. We'll be here for it. All three of us."

Emily made a small sound, half laugh and half something else, and her fingers tightened hard around his. Clara's hand was steady, but her eyes had gone bright, and she was smiling in a way Adam hadn't seen her smile since before the boat — open, unguarded, a little bit wrecked.

"Well," Clara said. "There it is, then."

"There it is," Emily echoed.

The fire cracked and settled, and the three of them sat with their hands joined over the last of the smoked fish, and beyond the treeline the sea went on hushing itself, patient, indifferent, waiting for whatever came next.

The fire had burned down to a bed of coals by the time anyone moved, and when Clara finally let go of Adam's hand, it was to reach across and take the last piece of fish off the stone — not to eat it, but to turn it over, inspecting the underside the way she inspected everything, looking for the flaw.

"This is the last of the nine," she said. "You counted them this morning. I watched you count them."

"I did."

"And the rack's empty now. That's what we're eating. The last of it." She set the fish back down, wiped her fingers on the sand, and looked at the two of them with her chin tipped. "I'm not saying it to frighten anybody. I'm saying it because it's true, and because we've just sat here and decided a lot of things, and none of those things put a fish on the rack."

Adam let out a breath that was almost a laugh. "You pick your moments."

"I've always picked my moments. You just never noticed before." But her mouth had softened, and she reached over and pushed Emily's hair back off her shoulder, a mother's gesture, absent and certain. "Eat the rest of yours. You left half of it."

Emily looked down at her lap as if she'd forgotten the fish was there. She picked it up and ate it in three bites, watching Clara the whole time, and Adam watched her jaw work and her throat move and the way her eyes stayed fixed and considering. When she was done she licked her thumb clean and said, "There. Happy?"

"I'm never happy," Clara said. "I'm content. It's better."

The coals settled with a sound like paper crumpling. Adam got up and fed two pieces of driftwood into the ring, and the fire took them slowly, the bark curling and going orange at the edges before it caught. When he sat back down he sat closer than he'd been, his shoulder against Emily's, and she leaned into him without hesitating, the way she'd been leaning into him for a week now, her weight a fact rather than a question.

"I meant it," Emily said, quietly, into his shoulder. "All of it. I didn't say it to hear myself talk."

"I know you did."

"And you're not going to take it back tomorrow. When the sun's up and it's a different day and it feels like a mistake."

Adam turned his head and looked at her — the firelight on her freckles, the smudge of soot on her cheekbone she hadn't noticed, the stubborn set of her mouth. "I don't take things back," he said. "That's not a thing I do."

"No," Clara said from the other side of the fire, and her voice was dry and warm at once. "It's not. I've known that about him since he was six years old and told me he was going to build us a house, and then went out and started stacking rocks by the fence line."

Emily laughed — a real one, surprised out of her — and the sound of it went out into the dark and came back off the trees, thinner. "Did you get far?"

"He got three courses high before it fell on him." Clara's eyes were on Adam now, and the firelight made them darker than hazel, almost brown. "He sat in the rubble and didn't cry. Just looked at it. Then he started over."

"I don't remember that," Adam said.

"You wouldn't. You were six." She was quiet a moment, and then she said, "You've been building the same house ever since. Different rocks."

The words sat there, and Adam felt them settle somewhere under his ribs, and he didn't have an answer for them, so he did what he did with things he couldn't answer — he reached for something to do with his hands. He gathered the flat stone and the fish bones and the charred skin and carried them out past the fire ring to the edge of the sand, where the crabs would find them before morning, and he crouched there a moment in the dark with his back to the shelter and the sea hushing at him from beyond the treeline.

When he came back, Clara had moved. She was sitting with her back against the shelter post now, her legs stretched out in front of her, and she had taken the tattered skirt and spread it over her knees like a blanket against the night chill, though the night wasn't cold. Emily had shifted too, lying down on her side in the sand with her head on her folded arm, watching the fire through half-lidded eyes.

"Come here," Clara said, and patted the sand beside her. "You're doing the thing where you stand around looking at the horizon. There's no horizon in here. Sit down."

He sat. She put her hand on the back of his neck and her thumb found the knot at the base of his skull, and he let his head drop forward under the pressure, and something in his shoulders gave way that he hadn't known was holding.

"There," she said. "That's better. You carry the whole island in your neck. It's a wonder you can turn your head."

"Somebody has to carry it."

"Somebody does. It doesn't have to be you every hour of the day." Her thumb worked in slow circles. "We decided something tonight. That means something's different. It doesn't mean you get to stop being tired."

Emily's voice came from the sand, muffled, sleepy. "He's not going to stop. He doesn't know how."

"No," Clara said. "He doesn't." And her hand stayed on the back of his neck, and the fire threw its light up the tarp wall, and the three of them were quiet together in the way that had stopped being strange a week ago and had started, somewhere along the way, being the only thing that felt like home.

Comments

Be the first to share your thoughts on this chapter.