Questions at Supper
Hemlock & Penance · Chapter 2 of 3

Questions at Supper

Their nightly suppers become interrogations running both ways, and a moment of tending his wound turns the questioning into something far more dangerous.

“Your mother kept bees,” Caius said.

“Is that a question?”

“It’s in the parish tithe roll. Three hives, taxed at Michaelmas.” He tore a heel from the loaf and did not eat it. “What became of them?”

“They swarmed the week she died.” Isolde ladled leek broth into his bowl, then into her own. “Bees know.”

“Know what?”

“When a house has gone wrong.”

It was the fourth night, and the fourth supper at the scarred oak table in the kitchen behind the shop. The leak had found its way down through two floors and was ticking into a tin pail by the dresser. The candle bent and straightened between them as though it were under examination too. He sat in the chair her mother used to sit in. She had not told him so. She suspected he knew.

He asked his questions the way she weighed foxglove, exactly, with great attention to the final grain. Who bought from her, and what. Whether the miller’s wife had truly been barren eleven years before the green tonic, or only ten. Which herbs grew in the yard and which came dry from the Hollin pedlar and his painted cart. He never wrote anything down. A ledger would have frightened her less.

She gave him half-truths, cleanly cut. Some women were simply lucky. The miller’s wife had prayed a great deal.

“My turn,” she said, when he paused to drink. “How many have you burned?”

“That isn’t how an inquiry works.”

“It works however I like at my table. How many?”

“Eleven.”

She had expected a lie and had a retort ready for it. She put it away. “And how many deserved it?”

“I believed all of them did. At the time.”

“And now?”

He set his spoon beside the bowl, square to the edge, a man taught to put things where they belonged. “Now I would like to stop.”

“The Order lets its dogs off the leash?”

“After a last assignment. I petitioned, and the Prior granted it.” Something moved behind his face and was put away again, neatly. “This is the last.”

“How lucky for me,” Isolde said, “to be the end of something.”

The back door banged open on a gust of wet. Agnes came through it sideways with a cloth-wrapped loaf held to her chest, her kerchief soaked dark and her cheeks scarlet from the ovens and the wind. She looked at Caius the way she would look at a rat in her flour bin.

“Rosemary,” she said, and set the loaf down hard enough to make the candle jump. “Eat it warm or don’t bother. Evening, Inquisitor.”

“Mistress Holloway.”

Agnes turned to Isolde. “He knows my name.”

“He knows everyone’s name.”

Agnes made a noise in her throat and went to warm her hands at the hearth. For a while she talked about nothing: the price of salt, the Dunlin boy’s new teeth, the gull that had got into the chapel. Then, with her back to them, she went on in the same easy voice. “Tom Fell came in from Hollin market at noon. Says there are riders on the north road. Grey cloaks with red piping. Six of them, putting up at the Bell in Saltcote.” She turned round, and her hazel eyes went straight to Caius. “Tom says they were asking after an inquisitor. Seemed put out to hear he’d gone on ahead alone.”

Caius said nothing. He had gone very still, like a man listening to a floorboard behind him.

“Those are the Prior’s men,” Agnes said. “Aren’t they?”

“Thank you for the bread,” said Caius.

Agnes left the way she had come. The look she threw Isolde over her shoulder said bolt the door, and it also said several other things that Isolde chose not to read.

. . .

He rose when the broth was gone. “I’ll wash before the water’s cold.”

“There’s soap on the sill. Don’t use the lavender. That’s for selling.”

He took the jug through to the scullery and drew the curtain, and she heard the water pour. His greatcoat hung steaming on the peg by the fire. She had offered to dry it, and after a moment he had let her. It smelled of rain and smoke and of him.

She was across the kitchen before she had decided to move.

The coat was as heavy as a wet sail. She went through it the way she went through a basket of mushrooms, fast and without much hope. The outer pockets held a flint and steel, a twist of salt and a stub of chalk. The left inner pocket held a string of iron beads worn smooth by a thumb. The right inner pocket, where she had watched the writ vanish, held nothing. She ran her fingers down every seam of the lining and found nothing there either.

The curtain rattled.

She did not jump. She settled the coat straight on its peg, smoothed the collar and turned around.

He stood in the scullery doorway in shirt and trousers, sleeves rolled to the elbow, water darkening the charcoal cloth at his collar. His forearms were corded and scarred. Just visible where the shirt gaped at his throat was the folded edge of heavy foxed paper, lying flat against his skin.

“You’ll have to try harder than that,” he said mildly, and sat back down.

She went to the hearth because her hands needed something to do. “You let me.”

“I wanted to see how you’d go about it.” He reached past her, bare-handed, for the kettle on its iron hook. “You were quick. Thorough. Very quiet.” His fingers closed on the handle. “You’ve done that before.”

Then he hissed and let go, and the kettle swung back on its hook, spitting.

“Sit,” she said.

“It’s nothing.”

“That’s iron that’s been hanging in my fire for an hour. Sit.”

He sat. She took down the stoneware pot of comfrey salve and a roll of clean linen and drew the other chair close, so close their knees bracketed each other. Then she held out her hand.

He looked at it for a while. Then he laid his own in it, palm up.

The burn was a livid bar across the heel of his hand and already lifting. She cooled it first with a cloth wrung out of the well-water pail, and he did not flinch. Then she smoothed on the salve with two fingers, slowly, from the centre outward, the way her mother had taught her. His hand was very warm, and her stained fingertips looked small against it. The leak ticked into its pail and the fire settled, and neither of them said a word.

She wound the linen once round the palm, twice, then across the back. To tie it off she had to hold his wrist still, and her thumb came to rest on the inside of it, where the skin was thin and the pulse lay close under it.

His pulse was not slow.

She tied the knot, and she left her thumb where it was.

“Isolde.” It was the first time he had used her given name. His voice had dropped so low she felt it more than heard it. “Have you ever used magic on a man?”

She looked up. His storm-grey eyes were very near and very steady, and they were not an inquisitor’s eyes at all.

“No,” she said. “I’ve never needed to.”

She still did not let go of his hand, and he did not take it back.

. . .

At midnight Caius Varne walked the length of the attic and back. It was eleven paces. He had counted them so many times that the boards had learned his weight.

His palm throbbed under the linen. Beneath that throb, at the wrist, he could still feel exactly where her thumb had been.

Six riders. The Prior had granted his release with his own soft hand and his own soft smile. Alone, Caius, he had said. I trust no one else with this. Now six men in grey were waiting two villages north.

He touched the writ against his chest. The wax was warm from his skin.

He should sleep. He should keep his door, his questions and his distance, finish this, and walk away.

Instead he turned the sprig of rosemary he had pulled from the crust of her friend’s loaf, round and round in his fingers, for a long time.

. . .

Isolde lay awake and listened to him pace. Then the pacing stopped, and the stairs began, one long slow complaint after another, all the way down.

She sat up in the dark and put her hand on the knife under her bolster.

The steps stopped on the other side of the bolted door. For a long moment there was no sound but the rain.

Then something whispered across the boards, and the stairs began again, going up.

She waited until the attic floor took his weight before she lit the candle and crept out barefoot. On her side of the door, pushed through the gap above the sill, lay a single sprig of rosemary.

Rosemary for remembrance, her mother would have said.

Or rosemary for a warning. She stood holding it until the candle guttered, and she could not decide which.

Comments

Be the first to share your thoughts on this chapter.