The Devil's Witness
Reading from

The Devil's Witness

14 chapters • 4 views
The Interrogation Room
1
Chapter 1 of 14

The Interrogation Room

The table was cold metal. Mara pressed her palms flat against it, the chill seeping into her bones, a different cold than the pines. Across from her, Dana Reyes set down a file, her expression unreadable. 'They found your prints on the needle, Mara. On the gate key.' The fluorescent light hummed. Mara's own reflection in the one-way glass stared back—a detective in an orange jumpsuit, the blood long washed from her hands, but the guilt of leaving Mila in the dark etched deep.

The cuffs came off first. That was the thing she noticed — not the cold, not the smell of stale coffee and floor wax, but the way the steel left her wrists and the blood rushed back into her fingers, hot and prickling, and she had to stop herself from rubbing them. She wouldn't give them that. She flexed her hands once under the table, slow, where no one could see, and let the feeling come back into them on its own time.

The room was bare the way interrogation rooms were always bare, and she'd sat on the other side of a hundred of them. Metal table bolted to the floor. Two chairs, one on each side. A one-way glass panel set into the wall at an angle that made you feel watched from a direction you couldn't quite find. The fluorescent tube overhead buzzed at a frequency just under hearing and flickered once, twice, then held. Mara had spent fourteen years in rooms like this one. She'd never once thought about what the table felt like from the wrong chair.

She pressed her palms flat against the metal. Cold. Not the pine cold — not the needle-scatter of frost coming up through her knees, not the wet ground soaking through the torn dress, not the way the trees had gone quiet around her while she ran. This was a dry cold, a manufactured cold, the cold of a building that didn't want you comfortable. She kept her hands there anyway, letting it climb her forearms, because the alternative was to sit with her hands in her lap like a woman waiting to be told what she was.

They'd given her an orange jumpsuit and a pair of paper slippers. The jumpsuit was two sizes too big at the shoulders and too short in the leg, and the fabric had that institutional stiffness that never softened no matter how many times it was washed. Her hair was still pulled back — no one had taken the band out — but it had come loose at the sides, and she could feel strands stuck to her temple where the sweat had dried. The blood was gone. That was something. They'd scrubbed it off her hands at intake with a brush that had been worse than the blood.

In the glass, her own reflection stared back at her. A woman with sharp brown eyes and a lean face and a ponytail that had given up. A detective in an orange jumpsuit. She looked at the reflection the way she'd look at a suspect — cataloguing, cold, waiting for it to give something up — and the reflection looked back with the same flat patience, and neither of them blinked.

She thought about Mila.

She'd been thinking about Mila for a week. Not constantly — the body didn't let you do that, the body made you sleep and eat and answer questions and use the bathroom, and every time she came back to herself she found the thought waiting exactly where she'd left it. Mila in the pines. Mila with Adrian's silk knotted twice at her throat, cold now, unable to get it off. Mila calling out into the dark and getting no answer, because Mara had been running the other way with the gate key in her fist and Rosa's blood drying on her hands.

The door opened.

Dana Reyes came in the way she did everything — without ceremony, without hurry, a file folder in one hand and a paper cup of coffee in the other. She set the cup down on the far corner of the table, out of reach, and sat. She was in uniform, the silver badge catching the light, her dark hair pulled back into the same tight bun she'd worn the night she took Mara's call. The small scar on her left eyebrow was pale against her skin. She looked at Mara for a long moment before she said anything, and Mara looked back, and neither of them offered the other a way in.

"You want to tell me how you're doing," Dana said. Not a question.

"I want to tell you where Mila is."

"We're looking for Mila."

"You're looking in the wrong places."

Dana set the file down on the table between them. It was worn at the edges, creased along one corner where it had been folded into a pocket or a bag, and Mara could see the thickness of it — more than a night's work. Dana's hand rested on the cover for a second, fingers spread, and then she pulled it back and let it sit there.

"We searched the pines," Dana said. "Both sides of the service road, out to the county line. State police ran dogs. Nothing. No sign of her, no sign she was ever there."

"She was there."

"I believe you."

Mara waited for the but. It didn't come. Dana just sat there with her hands folded on the table, watching her, and the fluorescent light hummed, and somewhere down the hall a door opened and closed and a man laughed at something. The ordinary sounds of a precinct going about its day. Mara had made those sounds herself, once. She'd walked those halls with a coffee in her hand and a case in her head and the certainty that the job was the job and she was good at it.

"How long have I been here," Mara said.

"A week."

"And in a week, nobody's found her."

"Nobody's found her." Dana's jaw tightened, just slightly, the way it did when she was about to say something she'd rather not. "Nobody's found Sofia Delgado either. She left the bus stop before our people got there. Bought a ticket with cash she didn't have. Nobody's seen her since."

"Sofia got out."

Mara let that sit. Sofia had gotten out — barefoot, in a maid's uniform, with a collar still buckled around her throat and Luis's keyring in her fist. Mara had watched her get into a stranger's car and drive east, and she'd stood in the gas station with the phone to her ear and let her go, because there hadn't been any other choice. She wondered where Sofia was now. Whether she'd gotten the collar off. Whether she'd found somewhere to sleep that wasn't a mattress seam in a servant's room.

She wondered whether Sofia hated her for leaving Elle.

"I need to ask you about the night of the twenty-third," Dana said.

"I've told it."

"You've told a version of it."

"I've told the truth."

Dana opened the file. She didn't look at it — she kept her eyes on Mara the whole time, her hand moving over the pages like she knew them by heart — and that was when Mara understood that whatever was in there, Dana had already read it. Already made up her mind about it. Already decided how this conversation was going to go, and was just waiting for Mara to catch up.

"Walk me through the gate," Dana said.

"I already—"

"Walk me through it again."

Mara breathed out through her nose. The table was still cold under her palms. She curled her fingers against it, once, and let them go flat again.

"I came through the gate from the inside," she said. "Sofia had the key. She'd taken it off the gardener — Luis, the old man who works the east lawn — earlier that night. She used it to open the south gate. I went through after her. I had the key in my hand when I went through. I was running. I didn't stop to close the gate behind me."

"And before that."

"Before that, I was in the house."

"Doing what."

"Looking for a way out."

Dana's eyes didn't move. "And before that."

Mara was quiet.

"Before that," Dana said, "you were in the kitchen with Rosa Alvarez. Six years in that house. Forty-one years old. Mother of two." She turned a page without looking at it. "She was found with a needle in her neck. A veterinary needle, loaded with enough pentobarbital to stop a horse. You know anything about that?"

"I know what I did."

"Say it."

"I killed her."

The words came out flat, the way she'd been trained to say them, the way she'd said them a hundred times in a hundred rooms about a hundred other people. But they didn't sit flat in her chest. They sat like something with edges. She'd put that needle into Rosa's neck because Rosa had been about to scream, and a scream would have brought Kyle, would have brought Adrian, would have brought the whole house down on the three of them before they got to the gate — and she'd made the call in a half-second with her hand over Rosa's mouth and the needle already in her fist, and Rosa's eyes had gone wide and then soft and then nothing, and Mara had lowered her to the kitchen floor and taken the tray of food she'd been carrying and set it on the counter like it mattered, like any of it mattered, and then she'd run.

"She brought Sofia a lunch tray," Mara said. "A week before. Sofia told me. Rosa noticed she looked pale and saved her a tray. That's the kind of person she was."

"That's the kind of person you killed."

"Yes."

Dana let the silence do its work. She was good at it — better than Mara had ever been, maybe, because she'd never needed the silence to be about her. She just sat there with her hands folded and her eyes steady and let the room fill up with what Mara had just said, and Mara sat inside it and didn't look away, because looking away would have been the first crack and she wasn't going to give Dana the first crack.

"They found your prints on the needle," Dana said.

"I told you they would."

"They found your prints on the gate key."

"I told you that too."

"They found your prints on the inside of the south gate, on the latch, on the frame." Dana's voice was even, almost gentle, and that was worse than if she'd shouted. "They found your DNA on a torn dress in the pines off the service road. They found your blood on a towel in a bathroom on the second floor. They found your fingerprints on a doorknob in the east wing." She paused. "The Sterling brothers have retained counsel. They've provided a timeline. They've provided witnesses."

"What witnesses."

"Staff."

"What staff."

Dana didn't answer that one. She turned another page, still without looking at it, and Mara watched her hand move and understood that whatever was on that page, Dana had decided not to show her. Not yet. Maybe not ever.

"The story they're telling," Dana said, "is that you came to the property that night without authorization. That you were looking for Sofia Delgado — who, they say, had been fired earlier that week for theft. That you entered the house through an unlocked service door. That you were found in the kitchen by Rosa Alvarez, who confronted you, and that you — a detective with fourteen years on the force, trained in restraint and control — chose to put a needle in her neck instead of identifying yourself."

"That's not what happened."

"Then tell me what happened."

"I told you what happened."

"You told me you killed her. You didn't tell me why."

Mara leaned forward. The table was cold under her forearms now, and she didn't care. "I killed her because she was about to scream. I killed her because if she screamed, Kyle Sterling would have come down those stairs, and Sofia and I would never have gotten out, and Mila—" She stopped. Her voice had climbed, just slightly, and she pulled it back down. "Mila was already in the pines. I don't know where she is. I don't know if she's alive. I killed a woman to keep a door open, and the door closed anyway, and I've been sitting in this room for a week telling myself that's the worst thing I've ever done, and every time I say it out loud it gets worse instead of better."

Dana looked at her for a long moment.

"You know what I think," Dana said.

"Tell me."

"I think you're telling the truth about the gate. I think you're telling the truth about Rosa. I think you went into that house for a reason, and I think the reason was a woman named Sofia Delgado, and I think there's a piece of this you're still not saying." She closed the file. "And I think the Sterling brothers know exactly what that piece is, and they're counting on you not to say it, because the second you do, they'll have a name to put on a different story."

Mara didn't answer.

"They're not charging you yet," Dana said. "They're building. They've got the prints, they've got the timeline, they've got staff statements they've had a week to draft with three lawyers in the room. They've got a dead woman and a missing woman and a detective in an orange jumpsuit with blood on her hands. What they don't have is a motive that holds, and that's the only reason you're still in this room and not in a cell across the river." She stood. "I've got about forty-eight hours before they decide they don't need the motive. After that, I can't help you."

"You're helping me now?"

"I'm sitting in a room with you." Dana picked up her coffee, which had gone cold, and didn't drink it. "That's what I've got."

She walked to the door. Her hand was on the handle when Mara said it.

"Elle Shelby."

Dana stopped.

"She's still in the house," Mara said. "She never left. Sofia and I went through the gate and she stayed behind. Kyle Sterling had her cuffed to a frame in his office and she was still there when we ran. She's the only person who saw everything. She's the only person who can tell you what that house is."

Dana turned. Her face was unreadable, but her jaw had tightened again, and her hand was still on the door.

"Elle Shelby," she said. "The lawyer."

"The lawyer."

"The Sterling brothers' counsel says she's on a sabbatical. Says she's been traveling. Says she hasn't been on the property in months." Dana's eyes didn't move. "They've got a signed statement with her name on it."

Mara felt something go cold in her chest that had nothing to do with the table.

"When was it signed," she said.

"Three days ago."

"She didn't sign that."

"It's got her signature."

"She didn't sign that." Mara's hands were flat on the table again, and she could feel the metal under her palms, cold and real and bolted to the floor, and she pressed down until her wrists ached. "Elle Shelby has been in that house for two weeks. She was cuffed to a frame in Kyle Sterling's office the night I left. She watched Sofia and me go through the gate and she couldn't follow us because he'd chained her there. She's not on a sabbatical. She's not traveling. She's in that house, and if she signed a statement three days ago, somebody put a pen in her hand and stood over her while she did it."

Dana was quiet for a long moment. The fluorescent light flickered once and steadied.

"You're telling me," Dana said, "that a woman who has not been reported missing, who has not filed a complaint, who has signed a statement in her own hand saying she's fine and out of the country, is being held against her will on a property we've already searched."

"I'm telling you she's the only witness who can corroborate what I'm saying. And I'm telling you she's the only person in that house who never got out."

Dana looked at her. There was something behind her eyes — not belief, not yet, but not dismissal either. A door that had been closed a moment ago and was now, very slightly, ajar. Mara watched her see it. Watched her decide, in the space of a breath, not to say whatever she was thinking.

"I'll make a call," Dana said.

She opened the door and stepped out, and the door closed behind her with a sound like a lock turning, and Mara was alone again with the cold table and the humming light and her own reflection in the glass.

She looked at the reflection for a long time. A detective in an orange jumpsuit. A woman who had killed a kitchen maid to keep a door open. A woman who had run through the pines with a gate key in her fist and left a weather presenter in the dark and a lawyer chained to a frame and a cleaner to catch a bus with a collar still on her throat.

She thought about the pine needles under her knees, wet and cold and sharp. She thought about the gate key, heavy in her hand, the teeth of it biting into her palm. She thought about the moment she'd stepped through the gate and the moment she'd turned and seen the house behind her, lit up and silent, and the moment she'd understood that she was never going to be able to unsee it.

She pressed her palms flat against the table and waited.

The light hummed. Somewhere down the hall, a door opened and closed. The file sat on the table between her and the empty chair, and she didn't touch it, because she knew what was in it, and she knew what wasn't, and the thing that wasn't in it was the only thing that mattered.

Elle. In that house. With a pen in her hand and Kyle Sterling standing over her.

Mara closed her eyes.

When she opened them, the reflection in the glass was still watching her, and the reflection was still a detective, and the reflection still had work to do.

Comments

Be the first to share your thoughts on this chapter.